This paper develops the approach to special relativity put forward by John S. Bell. The classical dynamics of an electron orbiting a nucleus in uniform motion is solved analytically and compared to numerical simulations for an accelerated nucleus. The relativistic phenomena of length contraction and time dilation are shown to result from the electric and magnetic forces on the electron when its motion is analyzed in a single frame of reference. The relevance of these results for understanding the theory of special relativity is discussed.
REFERENCES
1.
J. S.
Bell
, “ How to teach special relativity
,” Prog. Sci. Culture
1
, 135
–148
(1976
);Reprinted in
J. S.
Bell
and
A.
Aspect
, Speakable and Unspeakable in Quantum Mechanics: Collected Papers on Quantum Philosophy
, 2nd ed. ( Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge, 2004
).2.
P. A.
Tipler
and
R. A.
Llewellyn
, Modern Physics
( WH Freeman and Co.
, New York
, 2012
);J.
Taylor
,
C.
Zafiratos
, and
M.
Dubson
, Modern Physics for Scientists and Engineers
( University Science Books
, Mill Valley, CA
, 2015
).3.
H. R.
Brown
, “ The origins of length contraction: I. The FitzGerald–Lorentz deformation hypothesis
,” Am. J. Phys.
69
(10
), 1044
–1054
(2001
).4.
5.
6.
A.
Pais
, Subtle is the Lord: The Science and the Life of Albert Einstein
( Oxford U. P
., Oxford
, 2005
).7.
H. R.
Brown
, Physical Relativity: Space-Time Structure From a Dynamical Perspective
( Oxford U. P
., Oxford
, 2005
).8.
B. J.
Hunt
, “ The origins of the FitzGerald contraction
,” Brit. J. Hist. Sci.
21
(1
), 67
–76
(1988
).9.
O.
Heaviside
, “ The electromagnetic effects of a moving charge
,” Electrician
22
, 147
–148
(1888
); This paper and many other original works from the late 1800s and early 1900s can be found via www.wikisource.org.10.
J.
Bell
and
D.
Weaire
, “ George Francis FitzGerald
,” Phys. World
5
(9
), 31
–36
(1992
).11.
O. D.
Jefimenko
, “ Direct calculation of the electric and magnetic fields of an electric point charge moving with constant velocity
,” Am. J. Phys.
62
(1
), 79
–85
(1994
).12.
D. J.
Griffiths
, Introduction to Electrodynamics
, 4th ed. ( Cambridge U. P
., Cambridge
, 2017
).13.
G. F.
FitzGerald
, “ The ether and the earth's atmosphere
,” Science
13
(328
), 390
(1889
).14.
G. F. C.
Searle
, “ XVII. Problems in electric convection
,” Philos. Trans. R. Soc., A
187
, 675
(1896
);G. F. C.
Searle
, “ On the steady motion of an electrified ellipsoid
,” London, Edinburgh, Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.
44
, 329
–341
(1897
).15.
W. B.
Morton
, “ Notes on the electromagnetic theory of moving charges
,” London, Edinburgh, Dublin Philos. Mag. J. Sci.
41
(253
), 488
–494
(1896
).16.
D. V.
Redžić
, “ Image of a moving sphere and the FitzGerald–Lorentz contraction
,” Eur. J. Phys.
25
, 123
(2004
).17.
H.
Lorentz
,
A.
Einstein
,
H.
Minkowski
,
H.
Weyl
, and
A.
Sommerfeld
, The Principle of Relativity: A Collection of Original Memoirs on the Special and General Theory of Relativity
( Dover
, New York
, 1952
).18.
20.
A. I.
Miller
, “ A study of Henri Poincaré's “Sur la Dynamique de l'Électron
,” Arch. Hist. Exact Sci.
10
(3–5
), 207
–328
(1973
).21.
G.
Holton
, “ On the origins of the special theory of relativity
,” Am. J. Phys.
28
(7
), 627
–636
(1960
); Holton identifies eleven distinct hypotheses.22.
M.
Planck
, “ Das prinzip der relativität und die grundgleichungen der mechanik
,” Ver. Dtsch. Phys. Ges.
8
, 136
–141
(1906
); see also Sec. 29 of Pauli (Ref. 5).23.
A critical discussion of the “Lorentzian pedagogy” described by Bell can be found in
H. R.
Brown
and
O.
Pooley
, “ The origin of the spacetime metric: Bell's ‘Lorentzian pedagogy’ and its significance in general relativity
,” in Physics Meets Philosophy at the Planck Scale, edited by C. Callender and N. Huggett (Cambridge U. P., Cambridge, 2001), pp. 256–272; H. R. Brown, “Michelson, FitzGerald, and Lorentz: the origins of relativity revisited,” eprint http://philsci-archive.pitt.edu/987/ (2003). See also Brown (Ref. 7).24.
A.
Walstad
, ““ Relativistic” particle dynamics without relativity
,” Am. J. Phys.
86
(10
), 747
–749
(2018
).25.
A.
Einstein
, “ Das prinzip von der Erhaltung der Schwerpunktsbewegung und die Trägheit der Energie
,” Ann. Phys.
325
(8
), 627
–633
(1906
).26.
A.
Einstein
, “ Autobiographical notes
,” in Albert Einstein: Philosopher-Scientist
, edited by
P.
Schilpp
( Open Court
, New York, NY
, 1969
), pp. 1
–94
.27.
F. G. M.
Orlando
,
C.
Farina
,
C. A. D.
Zarro
, and
P.
Terra
, “ Kepler's equation and some of its pearls
,” Am. J. Phys.
86
(11
), 849
–858
(2018
).28.
J.
Franklin
, “ Electric field of a point charge in truncated hyperbolic motion
,” Eur. J. Phys.
36
(4
), 045015
(2015
).29.
See the supplementary material online the for MATLAB code (used to produce Figs. 3 and 4) as well as details of the implementation of the numerical method described in Appendix B.
30.
H. R.
Brown
and
O.
Pooley
, “ Chapter 4: Minkowski space-time: A glorious non-entity
,” Philos. Found. Phys.
1
, 67
–69
(2006
).31.
M.
Janssen
, “ Drawing the line between kinematics and dynamics in special relativity
,” Stud. Hist. Philos. Sci., Part B
40
(1
), 26
–52
(2009
).32.
O.
Pooley
, “ Chapter 15: Substantivalist and relationalist approaches to spacetime
,” The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy of Physics
(Oxford U. P., Oxford, 2013
), pp. 522
–586
.33.
H. R.
Brown
and
J.
Read
, “ The dynamical approach to spacetime theories
,” in The Routledge Companion to Philosophy of Physics
( Routledge
, New York
, 2021
), pp. 70
–85
.34.
D.
Dieks
, “ Bottom-up versus top-down: The plurality of explanation and understanding in physics
,” Scientific Understanding: Philosophical Perspectives
, edited by
H. W.
de Regt
,
S.
Leonelli
, and
K.
Eigner
(Pittsburgh U. P., Pittsburgh, 2009
).35.
The characterization of “principle” and “constructive” theories was given by Einstein in 1919, as discussed in
D. A.
Howard
,
M.
Giovanelli
, “ Einstein's philosophy of science
,” The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall 2019 Edition), edited by E. N. Zalta (Stanford University, 2019), <https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2019/entries/einstein-philscience/>; The terms “top-down” and 'bottom-up” are due to Dieks (in Ref. 34). See also Sec. 5.2 of Brown (Ref. 7).36.
As noted in Sec. II, Einstein understood that it was desirable to describe physical rods and clocks using a complete dynamical theory. Note that no classical account can fully achieve this goal, but also that the Lorentz-invariance of the full dynamical theory will ensure consistency. For a historical analysis of Einstein's thinking on this matter, see
M.
Giovanelli
, “ ‘But one must not legalize the mentioned sin': Phenomenological vs. dynamical treatments of rods and clocks in Einstein's thought
,” Stud. Hist. Philos. Sci., Part B
48
, 20
–44
(2014
); see also Sec. 4 of Brown and Pooley (Ref. 23), secs. 7.1 and 8.4 of Brown (Ref. 7).37.
O. D.
Jefimenko
, “ Direct calculation of time dilation
,” Am. J. Phys.
64
, 6
, 812
–814
(1996
);D. V.
Redžić
, “ Direct calculation of length contraction and clock retardation
,” Serb. Astron. J.
190
, 49
–58
(2015
);D. V.
Redžić
, “ Subtleties of the clock retardation
,” Eur. J. Phys.
36
, 065035
(2015
).38.
D. J.
Miller
, “ A constructive approach to the special theory of relativity
,” Am. J. Phys.
78
(6
), 633
–638
(2010
).39.
W. M.
Nelson
, “ Special relativity from the dynamical viewpoint
,” Am. J. Phys.
83
(7
), 600
–607
(2015
).41.
This was certainly true for Lorentz; the ultimate opinion of Poincaré is less clear; See Sec. II of
S.
Goldberg
, “ The Lorentz theory of electrons and Einstein's theory of relativity
,” Am. J. Phys.
37
, 982
–994
(1969
)and Sec. II of
S.
Goldberg
, “ Henri Poincaré Einstein's theory relativity
,” Am. J. Phys.
35
, 934
–944
(1967
);for an interesting perspective, see the “imaginary discussion” in
O.
Darrigol
, “ The electrodynamic origins of relativity theory
,” Hist. Stud. Phys. Biol. Sci.
26
, 241
–312
(1996
).42.
R. I.
McLachlan
and
G. R. W.
Quispel
, “ Splitting methods
,” Acta Numer.
11
, 341
–434
(2002
).© 2024 Author(s). Published under an exclusive license by American Association of Physics Teachers.
2024
Author(s)
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
