We point out that current textbooks of modern physics are a century out-of-date in their treatment of blackbody radiation within classical physics. Relativistic classical electrodynamics including classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation gives the Planck spectrum with zero-point radiation as the blackbody radiation spectrum. In contrast, nonrelativistic mechanics cannot support the idea of zero-point energy; therefore, if nonrelativistic classical statistical mechanics or nonrelativistic mechanical scatterers are invoked for radiation equilibrium, one arrives at only the low-frequency Rayleigh-Jeans part of the spectrum, which involves no zero-point energy, and does not include the high-frequency part of the spectrum involving relativistically invariant classical zero-point radiation. Here, we first discuss the correct understanding of blackbody radiation within relativistic classical physics, and then we review the historical treatment. Finally, we point out how the presence of Lorentz-invariant classical zero-point radiation and the use of relativistic particle interactions transform the previous historical arguments, so as now to give the Planck spectrum including classical zero-point radiation. Within relativistic classical electromagnetic theory, Planck's constant appears as the scale of source-free zero-point radiation.
References
1.
See, for example,
R.
Eisberg
and R.
Resnick
, Quantum Physics of Atoms, Molecules, Solids, Nuclei, and Particles
, 2nd ed. (Wiley
, New York
, 1985
);J. R.
Taylor
, C. D.
Zafiratos
, and M. A.
Dubson
, Modern Physics for Scientists and Engineers
, 2nd ed. (Pearson
, New York
, 2003
);S. T.
Thornton
and A.
Rex
, Modern Physics for Scientists and Engineers
, 4th ed. (Brooks/Cole
, Cengage Learning, Boston, MA
, 2013
).2.
H. B. G.
Casimir
, “On the attraction between two perfectly conducting plates
,” Proc. K. Ned. Akad. Wet.
51
, 793
–795
(1948
).3.
S. K.
Lamoreaux
, “Resource letter CF-1: Casimir force
,” Am. J. Phys.
67
, 850
–861
(1999
).4.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Van der Waals forces and zero-point energy for dielectric and permeable materials
,” Phys. Rev. A
9
, 2078
–2084
(1974
).5.
M. J.
Sparnaay
, “Measurement of the attractive forces between flat plates
,” Physica
24
, 751
–764
(1958
);S. K.
Lamoreaux
, “Demonstration of the Casimir force in the 0.6 to 6μm range
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
78
, 5
–8
(1997
);S. K.
Lamoreaux
, “Demonstration of the Casimir force in the 0.6 to 6μm range
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
81
, 5475
–5478
(1998
);U.
Mohideen
, “Precision measurement of the Casimir force from 0.1 to 0.9μm
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
81
, 4549
–4552
(1998
);H. B.
Chan
, V. A.
Aksyuk
, R. N.
Kleiman
, D. J.
Bishop
, and F.
Capasso
, “Quantum mechanical actuation of microelectromechanical systems by the Casimir force
,” Science
291
, 1941
–1944
(2001
);
[PubMed]
G.
Bressi
, G.
Carugno
, R.
Onofrio
, and G.
Ruoso
, “Measurement of the Casimir force between parallel metallic surfaces
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
88
, 041804
(2002
).
[PubMed]
6.
We will refer to both and as “Planck's constant”.
7.
See the discussion by
T. H.
Boyer
, “The contrasting roles of Planck's constant in classical and quantum theories
,” Am. J. Phys.
86
, 280
–283
(2018
).8.
T. W.
Marshall
, “Statistical electrodynamics
,” Proc. Cambridge Philos. Soc.
61
, 537
–546
(1965
).9.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Derivation of the blackbody radiation spectrum without quantum assumptions
,” Phys. Rev.
182
, 1374
–1383
(1969
).10.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Scaling symmetries of scatterers of classical zero-point radiation
,” J. Phys. A: Math. Theor.
40
, 9635
–9642
(2007
).11.
It is noteworthy that within quantum mechanics, there is no thought of consistent -scaling between mechanical systems and zero-point radiation. Thus, quantum mechanics involves only a -scaling connecting time and energy, with a completely independent scaling in length.
12.
H.
Goldstein
, C.
Poole
, and J.
Safko
, Classical Mechanics
, 3rd ed. (Addison-Wesley
, New York
, 2002
), pp. 452
–482
. There is a factor of 2π between the action variables in Goldstein's text and those used here, corresponding to the change from Planck's constant h over to .13.
14.
See for example,
B. H.
Lavenda
, Statistical Physics: A Probabilistic Approach
(Wiley
, New York
, 1991
), pp. 67
–70
.15.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Unfamiliar trajectories for a relativistic particle in a Kepler or Coulomb potential
,” Am. J. Phys.
75
, 992
–997
(2004
).16.
S. O.
Rice
, “Mathematical analysis of random noise
,” in Selected Papers on Noise and Stochastic Processes
, edited by N.
Wax
(Dover
, New York
, 1954
), pp. 133
–294
.17.
T. H.
Boyer
, “A connection between the adiabatic hypothesis of old quantum theory and classical electrodynamics with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Phys. Rev. A
18
, 1238
–1245
(1978
).18.
19.
J. H.
van Vleck
, “A correspondence principle for absorption
,” J. Opt. Soc. Am.
9
, 27
–30
(1924
).20.
An extensive account of the history of blackbody radiation is given by
T. S.
Kuhn
, Black-Body Theory and the Quantum Discontinuity 1894–1912
(Oxford U. P.
, New York
, 1978
).21.
22.
D. C.
Cole
, “Reinvestigation of the thermodynamics of blackbody radiation via classical physics
,” Phys. Rev. A
45
, 8471
–8489
(1992
).23.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Thermodynamics of the harmonic oscillator: Wien's displacement law and the Planck spectrum
,” Am. J. Phys.
71
, 866
–870
(2003
).24.
C.
Garrod
, Statistical Mechanics and Thermodynamics
(Oxford U. P.
, New York
, 1995
), p. 128
.25.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Understanding zero-point energy in the context of classical electromagnetism
,” Eur. J. Phys.
37
, 055206
(2016
).26.
See the appendix of
T. H.
Boyer
, “Random electrodynamics: The theory of classical electrodynamics with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Phys. Rev. D
11
, 790
–808
(1975
).27.
Quoted from Ref. 20, p.
112
.28.
29.
Quoted from Ref. 20, p.
195
.30.
A.
Hermann
, The Genesis of Quantum Theory (1899–1913)
, translated by C. W.
Nash
(MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA
, 1971
), pp. 8
–11
.31.
M. J.
Klein
, “Planck, entropy, and quanta 1901–1906
,” in The Natural Philosopher I
(Blaisdell Publishing Co.
, New York
, 1963
), pp. 81
–108
.32.
See for example,
D. J.
Griffiths
, Introduction to Electrodynamics
, 4th ed. (Pearson
, New York
, 2013
), Sect. 10.2.1, Eq. (10.26);L.
Eyges
, The Classical Electrodynamic Field
(Cambridge U.P.
, New York
, 1972
), Eqs. (11.45) and (11.46), p. 186
;J. D.
Jackson
, Classical Electrodynamics
, 3rd ed. (John Wiley & Sons
, New York
, 1999
), Eq. (6.48), p. 246
;A.
Zangwill
, Modern Electrodynamics
(Cambridge U.P.
, New York
, 2013
), Eqs. (20.57) and (20.58), pp. 724
–725
;A.
Garg
, Classical Electromagnetism in a Nutshell
(Princeton U.P.
, Princeton, NJ
, 2012
), Eqs. (54.16) and (54.17), p. 204
.33.
Quoted from
S.
Coleman
, Classical Electron Theory from a Modern Standpoint
(RAND Corporation Report
, Santa Monica, CA
, 1961
), p. 19
;reprinted in
Electromagnetism: Paths to Research
, edited by Doris
Teplitz
(Springer Science
, New York
, 1982
), Chap. 6, pp. 183
–210
.34.
J. H.
van Vleck
, “The absorption of radiation by multiply periodic orbits, and its relation to the correspondence principle and the Rayleigh-Jeans law: Part II. Calculation of absorption by multiply periodic orbits
,” Phys. Rev.
24
, 347
–365
(1924
). See also Ref. 19. Although he published a preliminary report, van Vleck never completed his work because he was sidetracked by the appearance of quantum mechanics.35.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Equilibrium of random classical electromagnetic radiation in the presence of a nonrelativistic nonlinear electric dipole oscillator
,” Phys. Rev. D
13
, 2832
–2845
(1976
);T. H.
Boyer
“Statistical equilibrium of nonrelativistic multiply periodic classical systems and random classical electromagnetic radiation
,” Phys. Rev. A
18
, 1228
–1237
(1978
).36.
R.
Blanco
, L.
Pesquera
, and E.
Santos
, “Equilibrium between radiation and matter for classical relativistic multiperiodic systems. Derivation of Maxwell-Boltzmann distribution from Rayleigh-Jeans spectrum
,” Phys. Rev. D
27
, 1254
–1287
(1983
);R.
Blanco
, L.
Pesquera
, and E.
Santos
“Equilibrium between radiation and matter for classical relativistic multiperiodic systems. II. Study of radiative equilibrium with Rayleigh-Jeans radiation
,” Phys. Rev. D
29
, 2240
–2254
(1984
).37.
A.
Einstein
, “Zur gegenwärtigen Stand des Strahlungsproblems
,” Phys. Z.
10
, 185
–193
(1909
).38.
See
H. A.
Lorentz
, Les Théories Statistiques en Thermodynamique
(B. B. Teubner Verlag
, Leipzig
, 1916
), p. 114
.Also,
S.
Tomonaga
, Quantum Mechanics
(North-Holland Publishing Co.
, Amsterdam
, 1962
), p. 298
.39.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Classical statistical thermodynamics and electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Phys. Rev.
186
, 1304
–1318
(1969
).40.
A.
Einstein
and L.
Hopf
, “Statistische untersuchung der bewegung eines resonators in einem strahlungsfeld
,” Ann. Phys.
33
, 1105
–1115
(1910
).41.
A.
Einstein
and O.
Stern
, “Einigen argumente für die annahme einer molekularen agitation beim absoluten nullpunkt
,” Ann. Phys.
40
, 551
–560
(1913
).42.
See Ref. 20, p. 319, Note 29. Kuhn mentions this Einstein-Stern calculation only in his notes to his text. Kuhn includes Einstein and Stern's closing remark; at the end of their successful calculation of Planck's spectrum, they comment, “It seems doubtful that the other difficulties will be overcome without the hypothesis of quanta”.
43.
T. W.
Marshall
, “Brownian motion of a mirror
,” Phys. Rev. D
24
, 1509
–1515
(1981
).44.
See for example, Griffiths' text in Ref. 32, p.
272
.45.
T. W.
Marshall
, “Random electrodynamics
,” Proc. R. Soc., A
276
, 475
–491
(1963
).46.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Diamagnetism of a free particle in classical electron theory with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Phys. Rev. A
21
, 66
–72
(1980
);T. H.
Boyer
“Derivation of the Planck radiation spectrum as an interpolation formula in classical electrodynamics with classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Phys. Rev. D
27
, 2906
–2911
(1983
);T. H.
Boyer
, “Understanding the Planck blackbody spectrum and Landau diamagnetism within classical electromagnetism
,” Eur. J. Phys.
37
, 065102
(2016
).47.
T. H.
Boyer
, “Derivation of the Planck spectrum for relativistic classical scalar radiation from thermal equilibrium in an accelerating frame
,” Phys. Rev. D
81
, 105024(10)
(2010
);T. H.
Boyer
“Classical physics of thermal scalar radiation in two spacetime dimensions
,” Am. J. Phys.
79
, 644
–656
(2011
);“
The blackbody radiation spectrum follows from zero-point radiation and the structure of relativistic spacetime in classical physics
,” Found. Phys.
42
, 595
–614
(2012
).48.
A recent brief review is given by
T. H.
Boyer
, “Any classical description of nature requires classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation
,” Am. J. Phys.
79
, 1163
–1167
(2011
).See also,
D. C.
Cole
and Y.
Zou
, “Quantum mechanical ground state of hydrogen obtained from classical electrodynamics
,” Phys. Lett. A
317
, 14
–20
(2003
).A review of the work on classical electromagnetic zero-point radiation up to 1996 is provided by
L.
de la Pena
and A. M.
Cetto
, The Quantum Dice—An Introduction to Stochastic Electrodynamics
(Kluwer Academic
, Dordrecht
, 1996
).© 2018 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2018
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
