Telegraphy originated in the 1830s and 40 s and flourished in the following decades but with a patchwork of electrical standards. Electromotive force was for the most part measured in units of the predominant Daniell cell, but each telegraphy company had their own resistance standard. In 1862, the British Association for the Advancement of Science formed a committee to address this situation. By 1873, they had given definition to the electromagnetic system of units (emu) and defined the practical units of the ohm as 109 emu units of resistance and the volt as 108 emu units of electromotive force. These recommendations were ratified and expanded upon in a series of international congresses held between 1881 and 1904. A proposal by Giovanni Giorgi in 1901 took advantage of a coincidence between the conversion of the units of energy in the emu system (the erg) and in the practical system (the Joule). As it was, the same conversion factor existed between the cgs based emu system and a theretofore undefined MKS system. By introducing another unit X (where X could be any of the practical electrical units), Giorgi demonstrated that a self-consistent MKSX system was tenable without the need for multiplying factors. Ultimately, the ampere was selected as the fourth unit. It took nearly 60 years, but in 1960, Giorgi's proposal was incorporated as the core of the newly inaugurated International System of Units (SI). This article surveys the physics, physicists, and events that contributed to those developments.
REFERENCES
1.
2.
See for example,
John
David Jackson
, Classical Electrodynamics
, 3rd ed. (Wiley
, New York
, 1999
), appendix.3.
The BIPM web site brochure, The International System of Units (SI), 8th ed. (
2006
), provides definitive definitions of SI units and background information; see <http://www.bipm.org/>.4.
See the National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST) web site, <http://www.nist.gov/index.html>, search under “primary frequency standards, NIST-F1” for updated value.
5.
Richard
Davis
, “The SI Unit of Mass
,” Metrologia
40
, 299
–305
(2003
).6.
Ian M.
Mills
et al., “Redefinition of the Kilogram: A decision whose time has come
,” Metrologia
42
, 71
–80
(2005
).7.
Ian
Robinson
, “Weighty matters
,” Sci. Am.
, 295
, 102
–109
(2006
).8.
Terry
Quinn
, From Artefacts to Atoms (Oxford U.P., New York, 2012
). This in depth text on the history of the BIPM and the development of measurement standards is written by a former director of the BIPM.9.
C. F.
Gauss
, “Intensitas Vis Magneticae Terrestris Ad Mensuram Absoluam Revocata
,” read before the Royal Society of Göttingen, December 1832; German translation can be found at <http://www.hathitrust.org/>, search under Ann. Phys. Chem.
27, 28
, 241
–273
and
–591
(1833
).10.
See Norman Feather,
Electricity and Matter
(Edinburgh U.P.
, Chicago
, 1968
), for a description of Gauss' experiments on magnetic forces, pp. 62
–68
.11.
Edmund
Whitaker
, A History of the Theories of Aether and Electricity (Dover edition, New York, 1989
), pp. 81
–88
.12.
Reference 10, pp. 72–80 and 91–105 provides accounts of the Biot-Savert study and Ampère's work, respectively.
13.
E. W.
Golding
, Electrical Measurement and Measuring Instruments
, 3rd ed. (Pitman and Sons
, London
, 1949
). See chapter one for equivalence of magnetic pole and electric current formulations.14.
Reference 11, p. 232. Whitaker points out that Gustav Robert Kirchhoff (1824–1887) first recognized the identity of c with the speed of light. Because Weber and Kohlrausch used a model of current in which there were negative and positive charge flows, a factor of two had been introduced when relating charge flow and charge and the identity with the speed of light was not obvious.
15.
James
Clerk Maxwell
, “Experiments on the Value of v, the Ratio of the Electromagnetic to the Electrostatic Unit of Electricity,” at <http://www.biodiversitylibrary.org/>, search under “Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science,” see 1869 report, pp. 436–438.16.
A. P.
French
, Special Relativity
(Norton
, New York
, 1968
). See chapter 8 for illuminating discussion of derivation of magnetic force through application of Coulomb's law and special relativity.17.
Sanford P.
Bordeau
, Volts to Hertz
(Burgess Publishing
, Minneapolis, MN
, 1982
), describes work of scientists for whom units of measure are named.18.
Herbert W.
Meyer
, A History of Electricity and Magnetism
(Burndy Library
, Norwalk, CT
, 1972
).19.
Franklin
Leonard Pope
, Modern Practice of the Electric Telegraph
, seventh edition, (Merchant Books
, 2007
). This handbook originally published in the 1860s–1870s, provides a glimpse into 19th century telegraphy. It can be found at <http://books.google.com/>; search under “Franklin Leonard Pope.”20.
Reports of the Committee on Electrical Standards
, edited by Fleeming
Jenkin
(British Association for the Advancement of Science
, 1873
), first through sixth report of the committee, from 1862–1869. This collection of reports can be found at <http://archive.org>; search under title. (Maxwell's experiment, Ref. 15, is included as an appendix to the 1869 report.)21.
Report of the British Association for the Advancement of Science (1873), pp. 222–225.
22.
B. W.
Petley
, “A brief history of the electrical units to 1964
,” Metrologia
31
, 481
–494
(1995
).23.
Transactions of the International Electrical Congress, St. Louis (1904), pp. 130–141;
G.
Giorgi
, “Unita Razionali di Elettromagnetismo
,” Atti dell' Associaz. Elettrotecnia Italiana, (1901), p. 402-18.24.
Giorgi-Heaviside correspondence can be found on the International Electrical Commission (IEC) web site, <http://www.iec.ch/>; search under “Giorgi.”
25.
G.
Giorgi
, “Memorandum on the M.K.S. System of Practical Units,” published by the IEC under, Advisory Committee No. 1 on Nomenclature, Section B: Electric and Magnetic Magnitudes and Units, June, 1934.26.
See
Harvey L.
Curtis
, Electrical Measurements
, (McGraw-Hill
, 1937
), for an idea of status of electrical units in the late 1930s. The emu, esu, and practical units were all in use. Note chapter XXI on the determination of the speed of light by evaluating the ratio of the emu and esu units of capacitance. This book can be found at <http://archive.org/>; search under “Harvey L. Curtis.”27.
Robert A.
Nelson
, SI: The International System of Units
, (AAPT
, December, 1982
), provides an in depth discussion and extensive references.28.
Reference 17, history of SI units can be found in concluding chapter.
29.
Neil M.
Zimmerman
, “A primer on electrical units in the Système International
,” Am. J. Phys.
66
, 324
–331
(1998
), explores several aspects of SI and realization of standards based on the Josephson and quantized Hall effects.30.
Francis B.
Silsbee
, “Systems of Electrical Units
,” Journal of Research of the National Bureau of Standards (former name before NIST)
, Vol. 66C
, April, 1962
, 137
–183
; can be found at the Ref. 4 web site.31.
Heinrich
Hertz
, Electric Waves
(Macmillan
, London
, 1893
; Dover, New York, 1962), a collection of Hertz's papers on wave propagation translated into English; see in particular, “The Forces of Electric Oscillations, Treated according to Maxwell's Theory,” 137–159 and “The Fundamental Equations of Electromagnetics for Bodies at Rest,” 195–240.32.
H.
Helmholtz
, “Uber absolute Maasssysteme für electrische und magnetische Grössen
,” Annalen der Physik
17
, 42
–54
(1882
).33.
Edward A.
Desloge
, “Relation between equations in the International, electrostatic, electromagnetic, Gaussian and Heaviside-Lorentz systems
,” Am. J. Phys.
62
, 601
–609
(1994
). This paper and included references provides a sense of the many articles devoted to systems of units.34.
Raymond T.
Birge
, “On Electric and Magnetic Units and Dimensions
,” Amer. J. Phys.
2
, 41
–48
(1934
);Raymond T.
Birge
, “On the Establishment of Fundamental and Derived Units, with Special Reference to Electric Units, Part I
,” Amer. J. Phys.
3
, 102
–109
(1935
);Raymond T.
Birge
, “On the Establishment of Fundamental and Derived Units with Special Reference to Electric Units, Part II
,” Amer. J. Phys.
3
, 171
–179
(1935
).© 2014 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2014
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
