A few months before its “official” discovery in September 1932 by Anderson at Cal Tech in Pasadena, the positron was almost simultaneously observed by no less than two additional research teams: one at Cavendish Laboratory in Cambridge, England, and one at Institut du Radium in Paris, France. In this paper, we examine this curious case of multiple independent observations by studying the primary literature. This study identifies the motivations that led these researchers to independently design the experiments suitable for the detection of this novel particle and shows that none of these teams were looking for a positive electron.
REFERENCES
1.
On the discovery of the positron see:
N. R.
Hanson
, “Discovering the positron
,” Br. J. Phil. Sci.
12
, 194–214
, 299
–313
(1961
);N. R.
Hanson
, The Concept of the Positron. A Philosophical Analysis
(Cambridge University Press
, New York
, 1963
) andM.
De Maria M
and A.
Russo
, “The discovery of the positron
,” Riv. Stor. Sci.
2
, 237
–86
(1985
) andX.
Roqué
, “The manufacture of positron
,” Stud. Hist. Philos. Mod. Phys.
28
, 73
–129
(1997
).2.
“
Cosmic rays disrupt atomic hearts
,” Sci. Newsl.
20 (1931
).3.
R. A.
Millikan
and C. D.
Anderson
, “Cosmic-ray energies and their bearing on the photon and neutron hypotheses
,” Phys. Rev.
40
, 325
–328
(1932
).4.
C. D.
Anderson
, “Energies of cosmic-ray particles
,” Phys. Rev.
41
, 405
–421
(1932
).5.
C. D.
Anderson
, Nobel Lecture, December 12, 1936. The Production and Properties of Positrons, Nobel Lectures, Physics 1922–1941 (Elsevier Publishing Company, Amsterdam, 1936). Anderson repeated again his account of the discovery of positron at a New York meeting devoted to “Topics in the history of modern physics” on February 3, 1961 (see C. D. Anderson, “Early work on the positron and muon,” Am. J. Phys. 29, 825–830; 826 (1961), and in a lecture at the “International symposium on the history of physics,” held at Fermilab in May 1980 (see C. D. Anderson, with H. L. Anderson, “Unraveling the Particle Content of Cosmic Rays,” in The Birth of Particle Physics, edited by L. M. Brown and L. Hoddeson (Cambridge U.P., New York, 1983), pp. 131–154; 140).6.
C. D.
Anderson
, “The apparent existence of easily detectable positives
,” Science
76
, 238
–239
(1932
).7.
C. D.
Anderson
, “The positive electron
,” Phys. Rev.
43
, 491
–494
(1933
).8.
On the development of the counter-controlled cloud chamber, see M. Leone and N. Robotti, “P M S Blackett, G Occhialini and the invention of the counter-controlled cloud chamber (1931–32),” Eur. J. Phys. 29, 177–189 (2008). For an account on earlier devices marrying cloud chamber and counter techniques, see M. Leone, “Particles that take photographs of themselves: The emergence of the triggered cloud chamber technique in early 1930s cosmic-ray physics,” Am. J. Phys. 79, 454–460 (2011).
9.
G.
Occhialini
, “Le recenti ricerche intorno all’elettrone positivo
,” La Ricerca Scientifica.
4
, 372
–373
(1933
).10.
11.
G.
Occhialini
G, letter to R. A.
Occhialini
(undated), Archivio Occhialini-Dilworth, University of Milan.12.
G.
Occhialini
, letter to R. A.
Occhialini
(June 1932
), Archivio Occhialini-Dilworth, University of Milan, Serie 2-M, Cart. 1, 013M, File 1.13.
G.
Occhialini
, letter to R. A.
Occhialini
(7 September 1932
), Archivio Occhialini-Dilworth, University of Milan.14.
P. M. S.
Blackett
and G.
Occhialini
, “Photography of penetrating corpuscular radiation
,” Nature (London)
130
, 363
(1932
).15.
P. M. S.
Blackett
and G. P. S.
Occhialini
, “Some photographs of the tracks of penetrating radiation
,” Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A
139
, 699
–727
(1933
).16.
Institut International de Physique Solvay
, Structure et Propriétés des Noyaux Atomiques
(Gauthier-Villars
, Paris
, 1934
).17.
P.
Dirac
, “Blackett and the Positron
,” in Cambridge Physics in the Thirties
, edited by J.
Jendry
(Adam Hilger
, Bristol
, 1984
), pp. 61
–62
.18.
For further details on Joliot and Curie’s works on positron in early 1930s, see
M.
Leone
and N.
Robotti
, “Frederic Joliot, Irène Curie and the early history of the positron (1932–33)
,” Eur. J. Phys.
31
, 975
–987
(2010
).19.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “Emission de protons de grande vitesse par les substances hydrogènes sous l’influence des rayons γ très pénétrants
,” C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris
194
, 273
–275
(1932
).20.
J.
Chadwick
, “Possible existence of a neutron
,” Nature (London)
129
, 312
(1932
).21.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “Effet d’absorption de rayons γ de tr`es haute fréquence par projection de noyaux légers
,” C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris
194
, 708
–711
(1932
).22.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “Projection d’atomes par les rayons tr`es pénétrants excites dans les noyaux légers
,” C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris
194
, 876
–7
(1932
).23.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “Sur la nature du rayonnement pénétrant excite dans les noyaux légers par les particules α
,” C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris
194
, 1229
–1232
(1932
).24.
25.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “Preuves expérimentales de l’existence du neutron
,” J. Phys. Radium
4
, 21
–33
(1933
).26.
Curie-Joliot to Bohr, 26 April 1932. Joliot-Curie Archives, Paris (JCA). See also Bohr Scientific Correspondence, Archives for the History of Quantum Physics (AHQP/BSC), Folder 157, Microfilm 21, Item 5.
27.
Bohr to Curie-Joliot, 30 April
1932
. JCA; AHQP/BSC, Folder 157, Microfilm 21, Item 2.28.
Bohr to Rutherford, 2 May 1932. AHQP/BSC, Folder 294, Microfilm 25, Item 162.
29.
Curie-Joliot to Bohr, 16 May 1932. JCA; AHQP/BSC, Folder 157, Microfilm 21, Item 3.
30.
Bohr to Curie-Joliot, 19 May 1932. JCA; AHQP/BSC, Folder 157, Microfilm 21, Item 4.
31.
I.
Curie
and F.
Joliot
, “New evidence for the neutron
,” Nature (London)
130
, 57
(1932
).32.
L.
Meitner
and K.
Philipp
, “Die bei neutronenanregung auftretenden elektronenbahnen
,” Naturwiss
21
, 286
–287
(1933
).33.
J.
Chadwick
, P. M. S.
Blackett
and G. P. S.
Occhialini
, “New evidence for the positive electron
,” Nature (London)
131
, 473
(1933
).34.
On the development of the Wilson cloud chamber, see
M.
Leone
and N.
Robotti
, “A note on the Wilson cloud chamber
,” Eur. J. Phys.
25
, 781
–791
(2004
). On the early phase of the cloud chamber’s existence, see
P.
Galison
and A.
Assmus
, “Artificial Clouds, Real Particles
,” in The Uses of Experiment: Studies in the Natural Sciences
, edited by D.
Gooding
, T.
Pinch
, and S.
Schaffer
(Cambridge U.P.
, New York
, 1989
), pp. 225
–274
.35.
D.
Skobeltzyn
, “The Early Stage of Cosmic-Ray Particle Research
,” The Birth of Particle Physics
, edited by L. M.
Brown
and L.
Hoddeson
(Cambridge U.P.
, New York
, 1983
), pp. 111
–119
.36.
G.
Occhialini
, letter to R. A.
Occhialini
(9 March 1933
), Archivio Occhialini-Dilworth, University of Milan.© 2012 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2012
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
