Selleri's paradox, based on an analysis of rotating frames, appears to show that the speed of light in an inertial system is not normally isotropic. This in turn seems at odds with the second postulate of special relativity requiring a universal light speed in inertial systems. First, it is demonstrated how to circumvent Selleri's argument using Einstein synchronization in rotating frames. Then the nature of Selleri's result is exposed: it simply corresponds to the adoption of a synchronization procedure different from Einstein's. In this scheme, anisotropic one-way speeds of light by no means contradict special relativity.

1.
R. J.
Kennedy
and
E. M.
Thorndike
, “
Experimental establishment of the relativity of time
,”
Phys. Rev.
42
,
400
418
(
1932
).
2.
H. E.
Ives
and
G. R.
Stilwell
, “
An experimental study of the rate of a moving atomic clock
,”
J. Opt. Soc. Am.
28
,
215
219
(
1938
).
3.
B.
Rossi
and
D. B.
Hall
, “
Variation of the rate of decay of mesotrons with momentum
,”
Phys. Rev.
59
,
223
228
(
1941
).
4.
M.
Kaivola
,
O.
Poulsen
,
E.
Riis
, and
S. A.
Lee
, “
Measurement of the relativistic doppler shift in neon
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
54
,
255
258
(
1985
).
5.
S.
Reinhardt
,
G.
Saathoff
,
H.
Buhr
,
L. A.
Carlson
,
A.
Wolf
,
D.
Schwalm
,
S.
Karpuk
,
C.
Novotny
,
G.
Huber
,
M.
Zimmermann
,
R.
Holzwarth
,
T.
Udem
,
T. W.
Hänsch
, and
Gerald
Gwinner
, “
Test of relativistic time dilation with fast optical atomic clocks at different velocities
,”
Nat. Phys.
3
,
861
864
(
2007
).
6.
J. C.
Hafele
and
R. E.
Keating
, “
Around-the-world atomic clocks: Predicted relativistic time gains
,”
Science
177
,
166
168
(
1972
).
7.
J. C.
Hafele
and
R. E.
Keating
, “
Around-the-world atomic clocks: Observed relativistic time gains
,”
Science
177
,
168
170
(
1972
).
8.
J.
Bailey
,
K.
Borer
,
F.
Combley
,
H.
Drumm
,
F.
Krienen
,
F.
Lange
,
E.
Picasso
,
W.
von Ruden
,
F. J. M.
Farley
,
J. H.
Field
,
W.
Flegel
, and
P. M.
Hattersley
, “
Measurements of relativistic time dilation for positive and negative muons in a circular orbit
,”
Nature
268
,
301
305
(
1977
).
9.
A. A.
Michelson
and
E. W.
Morley
, “
On the relative motion of the Earth and the luminiferous ether
,”
Am. J. Sci.
34
,
333
345
(
1887
). Available at http://en.wikisource.org/wiki/On_the_Relative_Motion_of_the_Earth_and_the_Luminiferous_Ether.
10.
A.
Brillet
and
J. L.
Hall
, “
Improved laser test of the isotropy of space
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
42
,
549
552
(
1979
).
11.
D.
Hils
and
J. L.
Hall
, “
Improved Kennedy-Thorndike experiment to test special relativity
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
64
,
1697
1700
(
1990
).
12.
V. W.
Hughes
,
H. G.
Robinson
, and
V.
Beltran-Lopez
, “
Upper limit for the anisotropy of inertial mass from nuclear magnetic resonance
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
4
,
342
344
(
1960
).
13.
R. W. P.
Drever
, “
A search for anisotropy of inertial mass using a free precession technique
,”
Philos. Mag.
6
,
683
687
(
1961
).
14.
V. A.
Kostelecký
and
C. D.
Lane
, “
Constraints on Lorentz violation from clock-comparison experiments
,”
Phys. Rev. D
60
,
116010
1
(
1999
).
15.
M. E.
Tobar
,
P.
Wolf
,
Sébastien
Bize
,
G.
Santarelli
, and
V.
Flambaum
, “
Testing local Lorentz and position invariance and variation of fundamental constants by searching the derivative of the comparison frequency between a cryogenic sapphire oscillator and hydrogen maser
,”
Phys. Rev. D
81
,
022003
(
2010
).
16.
D.
Mattingly
, “
Modern Tests of Lorentz Invariance
,”
Living Rev. Relativity
8
,
5
84
(
2005
), <http://www.livingreviews.org/lrr-2005-5, cited 31/5/2012//>.
17.
T.
Alväger
,
F. J.
Farley
,
J.
Kjellman
, and
L.
Wallin
, “
Test of the second postulate of special relativity in the GeV region
,”
Phys. Lett.
12
,
260
262
(
1964
).
18.
K.
Brecher
, “
Is the speed of light independent of the velocity of the source?
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
39
,
1051
1054
(
1977
).
19.
M. M.
Rogers
,
A. W.
McReynolds
, and
F. T.
Rogers
, “
A Determination of the masses and velocities of three radium B beta-particles
,”
Phys. Rev.
57
,
379
383
(
1940
).
20.
T.
Roberts
and
S.
Schleif
, “
What is the experimental basis of Special Relativity?
,”
Usenet Physics FAQ. University of California
, Riverside (
2007)
,
cited
01
June
2012
.
21.
C.
Will
, “
Special relativity: A centenary perspective
,” in
Einstein. Poincaré Seminar 2005
, edited by
T.
Damour
,
O.
Darrigol
,
B.
Duplantier
and
V.
Rivasseau
(
Birkhäuser Verlag
,
Basel
,
2005
), pp.
33
58
.
22.
E. F.
Taylor
and
J. A.
Wheeler
,
Spacetime Physics: Introduction to Special Relativity
, 2nd ed. (
W.H. Freeman and Co.
,
New York
,
1992
).
23.
While Boltzmann did have major problems in finding acceptance for his theory, there are hardly as many crackpots claiming to refute the foundations of irreversibility as there are disprovers of special relativity.
24.
The offside rule in soccer is definitely incompatible with special relativity. It explicitly refers to the position of a player at the moment when the ball is played at a distant location, not at the moment the player receives the ball. The first position is indefinite given that simultaneity of two distant events is involved, the second corresponds to a single well-defined event.
25.
J. M.
Supplee
, “
Relativistic buoyancy
,”
Am. J. Phys.
57
,
75
77
(
1989
).
26.
G. E. A.
Matsas
, “
Relativistic Archimedes law for fast moving bodies and the general-relativistic resolution of the ‘submarine paradox’
,”
Phys. Rev. D
68
,
027701
(
2003
).
27.
F.
Selleri
, “
Noninvariant one-way speed of light and locally equivalent reference frames
,”
Found. Phys. Lett.
10
,
73
83
(
1997
).
28.
R. D.
Klauber
, “
Comments regarding recent articles on relativistically rotating frames
,”
Am. J. Phys.
67
,
158
159
(
1998
).
29.
F.
Selleri
, “
Sagnac effect: End of the mystery
,” in
Relativity in rotating frames
(
Kluwer Academic Publishers
,
Dordrecht
,
2004
), pp.
57
78
.
30.
A.
Einstein
, “
Die Grundlage der allgemeinen Relativitätstheorie
,”
Ann. Phys.
354
,
769
822
(
1916
), English Translation in The Principle of Relativity (Methuen, 1923, Reprinted by Dover Publications, New York, 1952), pp. 109–164.
31.
Ø.
Grøn
, “
Relativistic description of a rotating disk
,”
Am. J. Phys.
43
,
869
876
(
1975
).
32.
K.
Kassner
, “
Spatial geometry of the rotating disk and its non-rotating counterpart
,”
Am. J. Phys.
80
,
772
781
(
2012
).
33.
G.
Sagnac
, “
L'éther lumineux démontré par l'effet du vent relatif d'éther dans un interféromètre en rotation uniforme
,”
C. R. Acad. Sci.
157
,
708
710
(
1913
), English translation in Relativity in rotating frames, eds. G. Rizzi and M. L. Ruggiero, (Kluwer Academic Publishers, Dordrecht, 2004), Chap. 2, pp. 5–7.
34.
This fact can be tested by exchanging light signals between the observers and verifying that for any given pair of observers O1 and O2, the light signals will always take the same time on the clock of O1(O2) to move from O1 to O2 (O2 to O1) and back.
35.
F.
Selleri
, “
Noninvariant one-way velocity of light
,”
Found. Phys.
26
,
641
664
(
1996
).
36.
This formulation does not properly take into account that the same laws may be given in different mathematical forms.
37.
Selleri believes (see Ref. 35) the second postulate to be a consequence of the first, which, in a proper formulation, it clearly is not.
38.
To Einstein synchronize clock B with clock A, send a light signal from B to A to be returned immediately with the clock reading of A. Then set the time on B to the time reading from A plus half the time span elapsed on B between emission and reception of the signal.
39.
E.
Minguzzi
and
A.
Macdonald
, “
Universal one-way light speed from a universal light speed over closed paths
,”
Found. Phys. Lett.
16
,
593
604
(
2003
).
40.
O.
Wucknitz
, “Sagnac effect, twin paradox and space-time topology—time and length in rotating systems and closed Minkowski space-times,” (
2004
), gr-qc/0403111v1.
41.
G.
Rizzi
and
A.
Tartaglia
, “
Speed of light on rotating platforms
,”
Found. Phys.
28
,
1663
1683
(
1998
).
42.
Having established a synchronization scheme for all observers between O and B, we may exclude time dilation effects of these observers with respect to each other.
43.
So that time dilation effects due to the motion with respect to local disk observers on the circle r = R are negligible.
44.
In this limit, the size of the time gap also tends to infinity.
45.
M. B.
Cranor
,
E. M.
Heider
, and
R. H.
Price
, “
A circular twin paradox
,”
Am. J. Phys.
68
,
1016
1020
(
2000
).
46.
A.
Einstein
, “
Zur Elektrodynamik bewegter Körper
,”
Ann. Phys.
322
,
891
921
(
1905
), English translation in The Principle of Relativity (Methuen, 1923, reprinted by Dover Publications, New York, 1952), pp. 35–65, “On the electrodynamics of moving bodies”.
47.
A.
Einstein
,
Relativity: The Special and the General Theory
, 15th ed. (
Crown
,
New York
,
1952
).
48.
R.
Anderson
,
I.
Vetharaniam
, and
G. E.
Stedman
, “
Conventionality of synchronisation, gauge dependence and test theories of relativity
,”
Phys. Rep.
295
,
93
180
(
1998
).
49.
D.
Bohm
,
The Theory of Relativity
(
W. A. Benjamin, Inc.
,
New York
,
1965
) reprinted by Routledge, Oxon, UK, 1996.
50.
t* is the time coordinate of a non-orthogonal frame (ct,x), while t and x are orthogonal to each other.
51.
A.
Grünbaum
, “
Logical and philosophical foundations of the special theory of relativity
,”
Am. J. Phys.
23
,
450
464
(
1955
).
52.
H.
Reichenbach
,
Axiomatik der relativistischen Raum-Zeit-Lehre
(
Vieweg
,
Braunschweig
,
1924
) English translation: Axiomatization of the Theory of Relativity (University California Press, Berkeley, 1969).
53.
R.
Mansouri
and
R.
Sexl
, “
A test theory of special relativity: I. Simultaneity and clock synchronization
,”
Gen. Relativ. Gravit.
8
,
497
513
(
1977
).
54.
G.
Rizzi
,
M. L.
Ruggiero
, and
A.
Serafini
, “
Synchronization gauges and the principles of special relativity
,”
Found. Phys.
34
,
1835
1887
(
2004
).
55.
Relativity in rotating frames
, edited by
G.
Rizzi
and
M. L.
Ruggiero
(
Kluwer Academic Publishers
,
Dordrecht
,
2004
).
56.
Due to time dilation, a(v)=1/γ(v), but we do not have to know this for our reasoning.
57.
Because we consider only two dimensions of space-time here, isotropy essentially means equality of the forward and backward speeds of light. Of course, these considerations can be extended to four dimensions and full space-time.
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.