We give six arguments that the Planck scale should be viewed as a fundamental minimum or boundary for the classical concept of spacetime, beyond which quantum effects cannot be neglected and the basic nature of spacetime must be reconsidered. The arguments are elementary, heuristic, and plausible and as much as possible rely on only general principles of quantum theory and gravity theory. The main goal of the paper is to give physics students and nonspecialists an awareness and appreciation of the Planck scale and the role it should play in present and future theories of quantum spacetime and quantum gravity.
REFERENCES
1.
Planck’s comments on his unit system preceded his discovery of the correct blackbody radiation law.
M.
Planck
, “Uber irreversible Strahlungsvorgange
,” Sitzungsberichte der Koniglich Preussischen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin
5
, 440
–480
(1899
).An earlier suggestion for a natural system of units was made by G. C. Stoney in 1874, based on , , and . See
J. D.
Barrow
, The Constants of Nature
(Vintage Books/Random House
, New York
, 2004
), Chap. 2. Stoney’s scale differs conceptually from Planck’s but is numerically close due to the coincidence that is roughly equal to to about an order of magnitude.2.
A. S. Eddington called attention to the Planck scale in 1918, and J. A. Wheeler later identified it as appropriate to quantum gravity, bringing it to the wider attention of theorists.
J. A.
Wheeler
, “Geons
,” Phys. Rev.
97
(2
), 511
–536
(1955
).For up-to-date values of the constants, see ⟨www.nist.gov⟩.
3.
R. J.
Adler
, “Gravity
,” in The New Physics for the Twenty-First Century
, edited by G.
Fraser
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 2006
), Chap. 2.4.
R. P.
Feynman
, Lectures on Gravitation
(California Institute of Technology
, Pasadena, CA
, 1971
), Lecture 3, notes taken by F. Morinigo and W. G. Wagner.5.
The most well-known candidate is (super)string theory. A nontechnical discussion is given by
M. B.
Green
, “Superstring theory
,” in The New Physics for the Twenty-First Century
, edited by G.
Fraser
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 2006
).A technical set of notes is available by
G.
t’Hooft
, “String theory lectures
,” ⟨www.phys.uu.nl/-thooft/lectures/stringnotes.pdf⟩.A popular discussion including other approaches is by
L.
Smolin
, Three Roads to Quantum Gravity
(Weidenfeld and Nicolson
, London
, 2000
).6.
An up-to-date technical reference is
Approaches to Quantum Gravity
, edited by D.
Oriti
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 2009
).In particular, see Chapter 1 by
C.
Rovelli
, “The unfinished revolution
,” in which he points out that the subject of quantum gravity dates back at least toM. P.
Bronstein
, “Quantentheories schwacher Gravitationsfelder
,” Phys. Z. Sowjetunion
9
, 140
–157
(1936
).7.
A list of quantum gravity theories is at ⟨www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_gravity⟩.
8.
See
A.
Akahito
, “How to build a Planck-mass accelerator in your solar system
,” Sci. Am.
260
(4
), 112
–115
(1989
). This article is apparently an April fool’s joke by T. Rothman using a pseudonym.9.
G.
Amelino-Camelia
, “Gravity-wave interferometers as quantum-gravity detectors
,” Nature (London)
398
, 216
–218
(1999
);10.
R. J.
Adler
, I.
Nemenman
, J.
Overduin
, and D. I.
Santiago
, “On the detectability of quantum spacetime foam with gravitational wave interferometers
,” Phys. Lett. B
477
, 424
–428
(2000
).11.
R. J.
Adler
, P.
Chen
, and D. I.
Santiago
, “The generalized uncertainty principle and black hole remnants
,” Gen. Relativ. Gravit.
33
, 2101
–2108
(2001
).12.
A brief introduction in the form of frequently asked questions is available at ⟨www.astro.caltech.edu/~ejb/faq.html⟩.
13.
One interesting example of many speculations on spacetime foam is by
J.
Ellis
, N. E.
Mavromatos
, and D. V.
Nanopoulos
, “Derivation of a vacuum refractive index in a stringy space-time foam model
,” Phys. Lett. B
665
, 412
–417
(2008
).14.
15.
For the history of quantum mechanics, see
H. C.
Ohanian
, Principles of Quantum Mechanics
(Prentice-Hall
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
, 1990
), Sec. 1.4.A classic in quantum theory is by
D.
Bohm
, Quantum Theory
(Prentice-Hall
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ
, 1951
), Chap. 5.An online reference is ⟨www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Introduction_to_quantum_mechanics⟩.
16.
For quantum theory in general, see
R.
Shankar
, Principles of Quantum Mechanics
, 2nd ed. (Plenum
, New York
, 1994
), Chap. 3.For a critical discussion of quantum mechanics and the uncertainty principle in particular, see
L. E.
Ballentine
, “The statistical interpretation of quantum mechanics
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
42
, 358
–381
(1970
).17.
M.
Born
and E.
Wolf
, Principles of Optics
, 7th ed. (Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 1959
), Chap. 10.18.
Also see Ref. 15, Sec. 5.3.
19.
E. R.
Taylor
and J. A.
Wheeler
, Spacetime Physics
(Freeman
, San Francisco
, 1963
), Chap. 1.20.
R. J.
Adler
, M.
Bazin
, and M.
Schiffer
, Introduction to General Relativity
, 2nd ed. (McGraw-Hill
, New York
, 1975
), Chap. 9.21.
C. W.
Misner
, K. S.
Thorne
, and J. A.
Wheeler
, Gravitation
(Freeman
, San Francisco
, 1970
), Chap. 39.22.
B. F.
Schutz
, A First Course in General Relativity
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 1985
), Chap. 1, on special relativity, and Chap. 8, on Newtonian limit.23.
C.
Will
, Theory and Experiment in Gravitational Physics
, revised ed. (Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 1993
), Chap. 4.24.
See Ref. 20, Sec. 6.2.
25.
See Ref. 20, Chap. 14.
26.
See Ref. 11, Chaps. 33 and 34.
27.
R. J.
Adler
and D. I.
Santiago
, “On gravity and the uncertainty principle
,” Mod. Phys. Lett. A
14
, 1371
–1381
(1999
);F.
Scardigli
, “Generalized uncertainty principle in quantum gravity from micro black hole Gedanken experiment
,” Phys. Lett. B
452
, 39
–44
(1993
).Also see Ref. 11.
28.
E.
Witten
, “Reflections on the fate of spacetime
,” Phys. Today
49
(4
), 24
–30
(1996
).29.
T.
Padmanabhan
, “Limitations on the operational definition of space-time events and quantum gravity
,” Class. Quantum Grav.
4
, L107
–L113
(1987
);L. J.
Garay
, “Quantum gravity and minimum length
,” Int. J. Mod. Phys. A
10
, 145
–165
(1995
).See also the string theory references in Ref. 5.
For cogent criticisms, see
Lee
Smolin
, The Trouble with Physics
(Houghton Mifflin
, Boston
, 2006
), in particular, Parts II and III.30.
B. N.
Taylor
and A.
Thompson
, “Guide for the use of the international system of units
,” NIST Spec. Publ.
811
, see sections 4 and 5 (2008
), and ⟨www.en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Metre#taylor2008a⟩.31.
J. Y.
Ng
and H.
van Dam
, “On Wigner’s clock and the detectability of spacetime foam with gravitational-wave interferometers
,” Phys. Lett. B
477
, 429
–435
(2000
);J. Y.
Ng
and H.
van Dam
, “Measuring the foaminess of space-time with gravity-wave interferometers
,” Found. Phys.
30
, 795
–805
(2000
);W. A.
Christiansen
, J. Y.
Ng
, and H.
van Dam
, “Probing spacetime foam with extragalactic sources
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
96
, 051301
-1–4 (2006
).
[PubMed]
32.
See for example, the website for LIGO, the Laser Interferometer Gravitational Wave Observatory, ⟨www.www.ligo.caltech.edu⟩.
33.
J. D.
Bjorken
and S. D.
Drell
, Relativistic Quantum Mechanics
(McGraw-Hill
, New York
, 1964
), Chap. 3.34.
Reference 33, Chap. 11, and
A.
Zee
, Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell
(Princeton U. P.
, Princeton, NJ
, 2003
), Chap. 1.36.
Wheeler coined many descriptive terms in use today, such as quantum foam and black hole. See
C. W.
Misner
, K. S.
Thorne
, and W. H.
Zurek
, “John Wheeler, relativity, and quantum information
,” Phys. Today
62
(4
), 40
–46
(2009
).37.
See Ref. 20, Chap. 11.
38.
C.
Quigg
, “Particles and the standard model
,” in The New Physics for the Twenty-First Century
, edited by Gordon
Fraser
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge
, 2006
).39.
See Ref. 34, Chaps. 7 and 8.
© 2010 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2010
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
