The cosmological Robertson–Walker metric of general relativity is often said to have the consequences that (1) the recessional velocity v of a galaxy at proper distance obeys the Hubble law v=H, and therefore galaxies at sufficiently great distance are receding faster than the speed of light c; (2) faster than light recession does not violate special relativity theory because the latter is not applicable to the cosmological problem, and because “space itself is receding” faster than c at great distance, and it is velocity relative to local space that is limited by c, not the velocity of distant objects relative to nearby ones; (3) we can see galaxies receding faster than the speed of light; and (4) the cosmological redshift is not a Doppler shift, but is due to a stretching of photon wavelength during propagation in an expanding universe. We present a particular Robertson–Walker metric (an empty universe metric) for which a coordinate transformation shows that none of these interpretation necessarily holds. The resulting paradoxes of interpretation lead to a deeper understanding of the meaning of the cosmological metric.

1.
C. H.
Lineweaver
and
T. M.
Davis
, “
Misconceptions about the big bang
,”
Sci. Am. (Int. Ed.)
292
(
3
),
36
45
(
2005
).
2.
T. M.
Davis
and
C. H.
Lineweaver
, “
Expanding confusion: Common misconceptions of cosmological horizons and superluminal expansion of the universe
,”
Publ. - Astron. Soc. Aust.
21
,
97
109
(
2004
).
3.
T. M.
Davis
,
C. H.
Lineweaver
, and
J. K.
Webb
, “
Solution to the tethered galaxy problem in an expanding universe and the observation of receding blueshifted objects
,”
Am. J. Phys.
71
,
358
364
(
2003
).
4.
Ø.
Grøn
and
Ø.
Elgarøy
, “
Is space expanding in the Friedman universe models?
,”
Am. J. Phys.
75
(
2
),
151
157
(
2007
).
5.
M. J.
Chodorowski
, “
Is space really expanding? A counterexample
,”
Concepts Phys.
IV
,
1
(
2007
).
6.
M. J.
Chodorowski
, “
Cosmology under Milne’s shadow
,”
Publ. - Astron. Soc. Aust.
22
,
287
291
(
2005
).
as an addition to
J. A.
Peacock
,
Cosmological Physics
(
Cambridge U.P.
,
Cambridge
,
1999
).
8.
J. A.
Morgan
, “
Are galaxies receding or is space expanding?
,”
Am. J. Phys.
56
,
777
778
(
1988
).
9.
M. A.
Abramowics
,
S.
Bajtlik
,
J.
Lasota
, and
A.
Moudens
, “
Eppur si espande
,” eprint arXiv:astro-ph/0612155v3.
10.
G. F.
Lewis
,
M. J.
Francis
,
L. A.
Barnes
, and
J. B.
James
, “
Coordinate confusion in conformal cosmology
,” eprint arXiv: 0707.2106v1 [astro-ph].
11.
M. J.
Francis
,
L. A.
Barnes
,
J. B.
James
, and
G. F.
Lewis
, “
Expanding space: The root of all evil?
,” eprint arXiv:0707.0380v1 [astro-ph].
12.
L. A.
Barnes
,
M. J.
Francis
,
J. B.
James
, and
G. F.
Lewis
, “
Joining the Hubble Flow: Implications for expanding space
,”
Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.
373
,
382
390
(
2006
).
13.
J. A.
Wheeler
, “
A septet of Sibyls: Aids in the search for truth
,” in
At Home in the Universe
, edited by
Robert N.
Ubell
(
AIP
,
New York
,
1996
), p.
9
.
14.
A scale factor of this form is a solution to the Friedmann equation for at least two special cases. One is a negatively curved empty universe (k=1 and Tμν=0). The other is a k=0 universe with the equation of state P=13ρc2.
15.
J. B.
Hartle
,
Gravity: An Introduction to Einstein’s General Relativity
(
Addison-Wesley
,
San Francisco
,
2003
), pp.
60
65
,
73
.
16.
E. F.
Taylor
and
J. A.
Wheeler
,
Spacetime Physics
(
W. H. Freeman
,
New York
,
1992
), p.
116
.
17.
Reference 15, pp.
368
372
.
18.
C. W.
Misner
,
K. S.
Thorne
, and
J. A.
Wheeler
,
Gravitation
(
W. H. Freeman
,
New York
,
1973
), p.
721
.
19.
E. A.
Milne
, “
A Newtonian expanding universe
,”
Q. J. Math.
5
,
64
72
(
1934
);
E. A.
Milne
,reprinted in
Gen. Relativ. Gravit.
32
,
1939
1948
(
2000
).
20.
A.
Einstein
, “
The foundation of the general theory of relativity
” in
The Principle of Relativity
(
Dover
,
New York
,
1952
), p.
116
.
21.
S.
Weinberg
,
Gravitation and Cosmology: Principles and Applications of the General Theory of Relativity
(
Wiley
,
New York
,
1972
).
22.
S.
Weinberg
,
Cosmology
(
Oxford U.P.
,
Oxford
,
2008
).
23.
P. J. E.
Peebles
,
Principles of Physical Cosmology
(
Princeton U.P.
,
Princeton
,
1993
).
24.
S. M.
Carroll
,
Spacetime and Geometry: An Introduction to General Relativity
(
Addison-Wesley
,
San Francisco
,
2004
).
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.