We present evidence that although students’ mathematical skills in introductory calculus-based physics classes may not be readily applied in physics contexts, these students have strong mathematical resources on which to build effective instruction. Our evidence is based on clinical interviews of problem solving in electrostatics, which are analyzed using the framework of Sherin’s symbolic forms. We find that students use notions of “dependence” and “parts-of-a-whole” to successfully guide their work, even in novel situations. We also present evidence that students’ naive conceptions of the limit may prevent them from viewing integrals as sums.
REFERENCES
1.
Andrea A.
diSessa
, “Toward an epistemology of physics
,” Cogn. Instruct.
10
, 105
–226
(1993
).2.
David
Hammer
, “Student resources for learning introductory physics
,” Am. J. Phys.
68
, S52
–S59
(2000
).3.
David
Hammer
, Andy
Elby
, Rachel
Scherr
, and Joe
Redish
, “Resources, Framing and Transfer
,” in Transfer of Learning from a Modern Multidisciplinary Perspective
, edited by Jose
Mestre
(Information Age Publishing
, Greenwich, CT, 2005
).4.
Bruce L.
Sherin
, “How students understand physics equations
,” Cogn. Instruct.
19
, 479
–541
(2001
).5.
Joan
Ferrini-Mundy
and Karen
Graham
, “An overview of the calculus curriculum reform effort: Issues for learning, teaching, and curriculum development
,” Am. Math. Monthly
98
, 627
–635
(1991
).6.
A.
Orton
, “Students’ understanding of integration
,” Educ. Stud. Math.
14
, 1
–18
(1983
).7.
Patrick. W.
Thompson
, “Images of rate and operational understanding of the fundamental theorem of calculus
,” Educ. Stud. Math.
26
, 229
–274
(1994
).8.
S.
Vinner
, “The avoidance of visual considerations in calculus students
,” Focus on Learning Problems in Mathematics
11
, 149
–156
(1999
).9.
L. C.
McDermott
, “Oersted Medal Lecture 2001: Physics education research: The key to student learning
,” Am. J. Phys.
69
, 1127
–1137
(2001
).10.
B.
Cornu
, “Limits
,” in Advanced Mathematical Thinking
, edited by David
Tall
(Kluwer Academic
, Boston, 1991
), pp. 153
–166
.11.
Lillian C.
McDermott
and Edward F.
Redish
, “RL-PER1: Resource letter on physics education research
,” Am. J. Phys.
67
, 755
–772
(1999
), and references therein.12.
David
Tall
and Shlomo
Vinner
, “Concept image and concept definition in mathematics with particular reference to limits and continuity
,” Educ. Stud. Math.
12
, 151
–169
(1981
).13.
Steven
Williams
, “Models of limits in college calculus students
,” J. Res. Math. Educ.
22
, 219
–236
(1991
).14.
Michael
Oehrtmam
, Ph.D. thesis, University of Texas
, Austin, 2002
.15.
D. O.
Tall
and R. L. E.
Schwarzenberger
, “Conflicts in the learning of real numbers and limits
,” Math. Teach.
82
, 44
–49
(1978
).16.
Randall
Harrington
, Ph.D. thesis, University of Washington
, 1995
.17.
Stephen
Kanim
, Ph.D. thesis, University of Washington
, 1999
.18.
Michael C.
Wittmann
, “The object coordination class applied to wavepulses: Analysing student reasoning in wave physics
,” Int. J. Sci. Educ.
24
, 97
–118
(2002
).19.
K. A.
Marrongelle
, Kelly
Black
, and Dawn
Meredith
, “Studio Calculus and Physics: Interdisciplinary Mathematics with Active Learning
,” in Integrated Mathematics: Choices and Challenges
, edited by Sue Ann
McGraw
(National Council of Teachers of Mathematics
, Reston, VA, 2003
), pp. 103
–115
.20.
David
Halliday
, Robert
Resnick
, and Jearl
Walker
, Fundamentals of Physics
(Wiley
, New York, 2003
), 6th ed.;Raymond A.
Serway
and Robert J.
Beichner
, Physics for Scientists and Engineers
(Saunders College Publishing
, Fort Worth, 2000
), 5th ed.21.
There was a typographical error in this question. The electric field should have been . As it stands, the electric field is essentially 0 during the very short time inside the plates. Only Georgette realized this error and was somewhat confused by it.
22.
Patrick W.
Thompson
and Jason
Silverman
, “The Concept of Accumulation in Calculus
,” in Making the Connection: Research and Teaching in Undergraduate Mathematics
, edited by M.
Carlson
and C.
Rasmussen
(Mathematical Association of America
, Washington, DC) (in press).23.
Corinne A.
Manogue
, Kerry
Browne
, Tevian
Dray
, and Barbara
Edwards
, “Why is Ampere’s law so hard? A look at middle-division physics
,” Am. J. Phys.
74
, 344
–350
(2006
).24.
E. F.
Redish
, “Problem Solving and the Use of Math in Physics Courses
,” in Proceedings of the Conference on World View on Physics Education 2005: Focusing on Change
, Delhi, India. (to be published), arXiv:physics/0608268.25.
The tutorial and homework are available at ⟨pubpages.unh.edu/∼dawnm/connectm&m.html⟩.
26.
27.
Edward F.
Redish
, Rachel E.
Scherr
, and Jonathan
Tuminaro
, “Reverse-engineering the solution of a simple physics problem: Why learning physics is harder than it looks
,” Phys. Teach.
44
, 293
–300
(2006
).28.
Jonathan
Tuminaro
, Ph.D. thesis, University of Maryland
, College Park (2004
).© 2008 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2008
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.