Two simple spin models are studied to show that the microcanonical entropy can be a non-concave function of the energy, and that the microcanonical and canonical ensembles can give non-equivalent descriptions of the same system in the thermodynamic limit. The two models are simple variations of the classical paramagnetic spin model of non-interacting spins and are solved as easily as the latter model.
REFERENCES
1.
Precise mathematical results expressing this statement can be found in
G.
Gallavotti
, Statistical Mechanics: A Short Treatise
(Springer
, New York, 1999
), Chap. 4, orO. E.
Lanford
, “Entropy and equilibrium states in classical statistical mechanics
,” in Statistical Mechanics and Mathematical Problems
, edited by A.
Lenard
(Springer
, Berlin, 1973
), pp. 1
–113
, Sec. A.2.
Systems with short-range interactions have concave entropies because they are additive; that is, they can be decomposed into non-interacting parts in the thermodynamic limit. Systems with long-range interactions are not additive, hence the fact that they can have non-concave entropies. See the first chapter of Ref. 3 for a good exposition of this reasoning.
3.
Dynamics and Thermodynamics of Systems with Long Range Interactions
, edited by T.
Dauxois
, S.
Ruffo
, E.
Arimondo
, and M.
Wilkens
(Springer
, New York, 2002
).4.
D.
Lynden-Bell
and R.
Wood
, “The gravo-thermal catastrophe in isothermal spheres and the onset of red-giant structure for stellar systems
,” Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.
138
, 495
–525
(1968
).5.
W.
Thirring
, “Systems with negative specific heat
,” Z. Phys. A
235
, 339
–352
(1970
).6.
P.
Hertel
and W.
Thirring
, “A soluble model for a system with negative specific heat
,” Ann. Phys. (N.Y.)
(N.Y.) 63
, 520
–533
(1971
).7.
D.
Lynden-Bell
, “Negative specific heat in astronomy, physics and chemistry
,” Physica A
263
, 293
–304
(1999
).8.
P.-H.
Chavanis
, “Phase transitions in self-gravitating systems
,” Int. J. Mod. Phys. B
20
, 3113
–3198
(2006
).9.
D. H. E.
Gross
, “Microcanonical thermodynamics and statistical fragmentation of dissipative systems: The topological structure of the -body phase space
,” Phys. Rep.
279
, 119
–202
(1997
).10.
I.
Ispolatov
and E. G. D.
Cohen
, “On first-order phase transitions in microcanonical and canonical non-extensive systems
,” Physica A
295
, 475
–487
(2000
).11.
J.
Barré
, D.
Mukamel
, and S.
Ruffo
, “Inequivalence of ensembles in a system with long-range interactions
,” Phys. Rev. Lett.
87
, 030601
–1
(2001
).12.
R. S.
Ellis
, H.
Touchette
, and B.
Turkington
, “Thermodynamic versus statistical nonequivalence of ensembles for the mean-field Blume-Emery-Griffiths model
,” Physica A
335
, 518
–538
(2004
).13.
M.
Costeniuc
, R. S.
Ellis
, and H.
Touchette
, “Complete analysis of phase transitions and ensemble equivalence for the Curie-Weiss-Potts model
,” J. Math. Phys.
46
, 063301
–1
063301
–25
(2005
).14.
R. S.
Ellis
, K.
Haven
, and B.
Turkington
, “Nonequivalent statistical equilibrium ensembles and refined stability theorems for most probable flows
,” Nonlinearity
15
, 239
–255
(2002
).15.
B.
Turkington
, A.
Majda
, K.
Haven
, and M.
DiBattista
, “Statistical equilibrium predictions of jets and spots on Jupiter
,” Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A.
98
, 12346
–12350
(2001
).16.
See, for example,
R. K.
Pathria
, Statistical Mechanics
, 2nd ed. (Butterworth Heinemann
, Oxford, 1996
), Sec. 3.9.17.
J. F.
Nagle
, “The one-dimensional KDP model in statistical mechanics
,” Am. J. Phys.
36
, 1114
–1117
(1968
).18.
H. S.
Leff
, “What if entropy were dimensionless?
,” Am. J. Phys.
67
, 1114
–1122
(1999
).19.
Other examples of one-dimensional models having phase transitions in the canonical ensemble can be found in
C.
Kittel
, “Phase transition of a molecular zipper
,” Am. J. Phys.
37
, 917
–920
(1969
) and Ref. 17.20.
Recall that the Legendre transform of yields when the latter is concave.
21.
See Refs. 22 and 25 for the complete calculation.
22.
H.
Touchette
, “A simple spin model with nonequivalent microcanonical and canonical ensembles
,” arXiv:cond-mat/0504020v1 (2005
).23.
H.
Touchette
, R. S.
Ellis
, and B.
Turkington
, “An introduction to the thermodynamic and macrostate levels of nonequivalent ensembles
,” Physica A
340
, 138
–146
(2004
).24.
H.
Touchette
and R. S.
Ellis
, “Nonequivalent ensembles and metastability
,” in Complexity, Metastability and Nonextensivity
, edited by C.
Beck
, G.
Benedek
, A.
Rapisarda
, and C.
Tsallis
(World Scientific
, Singapore, 2005
), p. 81
.25.
H.
Touchette
, “Equivalence and nonequivalence of the microcanonical and canonical ensembles: A large deviations study
,” Ph.D. thesis, Department of Physics, McGill University
, 2003
. Available at ⟨www.maths.qmul.ac.uk/∼ht⟩.26.
H.
Touchette
and C.
Beck
, “Nonconcave entropies in multifractals and the thermodynamic formalism
,” J. Stat. Phys.
125
, 455
–471
(2006
).27.
M.
Costeniuc
, R. S.
Ellis
, H.
Touchette
, and B.
Turkington
, “Generalized canonical ensembles and ensemble equivalence
,” Phys. Rev. E
73
, 026105
–1
(2006
).© 2008 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2008
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
