Although James Clerk Maxwell’s religious views and discussions on atoms having the properties of “manufactured articles” have been discussed, some aspects of the responses by his contemporaries to his remarks on creation have been neglected. Various responses quoted here include a book from 1878 by “Physicus” (George John Romanes) attributing “arrogance” to Maxwell for his inferences. Relevant aspects of the evolution of the perspective of Romanes are noted. A response by B. F. Westcott indicated that Maxwell was the author of a related anonymous publication concerned with what eventually became known as the heat death of the universe. In his teaching to theology students, Westcott, a friend of Maxwell, emphasized Maxwell’s reasoning based on the dissipation of energy. There are similarities between Maxwell’s perspective on creation and Biblical commentaries by fellow Eranus Club members Westcott and J. B. Lightfoot. Interest in Maxwell’s remarks extended into the twentieth century. The principal Baptist chapel attended by Maxwell and his wife when in London in the 1860s is identified and some relevant attributes of the chapel and of its pastor are described.
REFERENCES
1.
J. C.
Maxwell
, “Address to the Mathematical and Physical Sections of the British Association
,” Report of the 40th Meeting of the British Association for the Advancement of Science, 1
–9
(1870
);J. C.
Maxwell
,Nature (London)
2
, 419
–22
(1870
);2.
3.
4.
[For a review of the 1st ed., see
B.
Stewart
, Nature (London)
5
, 319
–320
(1872
).]5.
Anon. [
J. C.
Maxwell
], “Review of The Conservation of Energy
,” Nature (London)
9
, 198
–200
(January 15, 1874
).This is a review of a book by B. Stewart. In a review of a different book (one by B. Stewart and P. G. Tait), Maxwell mentions that book:
J. C.
Maxwell
, “Review of Paradoxical Philosophy
,” Nature (London)
19
, 141
–143
(1879
).6.
J. C.
Maxwell
, The Scientific Papers of James Clerk Maxwell
, edited by W. D.
Niven
(University Press
, Cambridge, 1890
), Vol. 2
.7.
Maxwell on Molecules and Gases
, edited by E.
Garber
, S. G.
Brush
, and C. W. F.
Everitt
(MIT Press
, Cambridge, MA, 1986
).8.
Maxwell on Heat and Statistical Mechanics
, edited by E.
Garber
, S. G.
Brush
, and C. W. F.
Everitt
(Lehigh University Press
, Bethlehem, PA, 1995
). A helpful list of secondary sources appears on pp. 499
–525
.9.
The Scientific Letters and Papers of James Clerk Maxwell, Vol. I, 1846–1862
, edited by P. M.
Harman
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 1990
).10.
The Scientific Letters and Papers of James Clerk Maxwell, Vol. II, 1863–1873
, edited by P. M.
Harman
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 1995
).11.
The Scientific Letters and Papers of James Clerk Maxwell, Vol. III, 1874–1879
, edited by P. M.
Harman
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 2002
).12.
L.
Campbell
and W.
Garnett
, The Life of James Clerk Maxwell
(Macmillan
, London, 1882
).13.
L.
Campbell
and W.
Garnett
, The Life of James Clerk Maxwell
(Macmillan
, London, 1884
), 2nd ed.14.
R. T.
Glazebrook
, James Clerk Maxwell and Modern Physics
(Cassell
, London, 1901
), pp. 54
–147
.15.
J. J.
Thomson
et al., James Clerk Maxwell: A Commemorative Volume, 1831–1931
(Macmillan
, New York, 1931
).16.
C. G.
Knott
, Life and Scientific Work of Peter Guthrie Tait
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 1911
).17.
C. W. F.
Everitt
, James Clerk Maxwell, Physicist and Natural Philosopher
(Scribner
, New York, 1975
).18.
C. W. F.
Everitt
, “Maxwell, James Clerk
,” in Dictionary of Scientific Biography
, edited by C. C.
Gillispie
(Scribner
, New York, 1974
), Vol. 9
, pp. 198
–230
.19.
I.
Tolstoy
, James Clerk Maxwell, a Biography
(University of Chicago Press
, Chicago, 1981
).20.
M.
Goldman
, The Demon in the Aether: The Story of James Clerk Maxwell
(Paul Harris
, Edinburgh, 1983
).21.
P. M.
Harman
, The Natural Philosophy of James Clerk Maxwell
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 1998
).22.
B.
Mahon
, The Man Who Changed Everything: The Life of James Clerk Maxwell
(Wiley
, Chichester, 2003
).23.
C.
Domb
, “James Clerk Maxwell in London: 1860–1865
,” Notes and Records Roy. Soc. London
35
(1
), 67
–103
(1981
).24.
H. T.
Bernstein
, “J. Clerk Maxwell on the history of the kinetic theory of gases, 1871
,” Isis
54
, 206
–216
(1963
);S. G.
Brush
, “James Clerk Maxwell and the kinetic theory of gases: A review based on recent historical studies
,” Am. J. Phys.
39
, 631
–640
(1971
).25.
D. B.
Wilson
, “Kinetic atom
,” Am. J. Phys.
49
, 217
–222
(1981
).26.
C.
Smith
, The Science of Energy: A Cultural History of Energy Physics in Victorian Britain
(Athlone
, London, 1998
), pp. 211
–267
, 340–350.27.
P.
Theerman
, “James Clerk Maxwell and religion
,” Am. J. Phys.
54
, 312
(1986
).28.
J. L.
McNatt
, “James Clerk Maxwell’s refusal to join the Victoria Institute
,” Perspectives on Science and Christian Faith
56
(3
), 204
–215
(2004
).29.
Physicus [
G. J.
Romanes
], A Candid Examination of Theism
(Houghton & Osgood
, Boston, 1878
), pp. 152
–156
.30.
The following list gives reference numbers within […] and internet locations: [Refs. 1, 29, and 83] ⟨www.gutenberg.org⟩; [Refs. 1, 2, 5, 40, 45, 47, and 67] ⟨http://digicoll.library.wisc.edu/HistSciTech/⟩; [Refs. 2 and 47] ⟨www.scholars.nus.edu.sg/victorian/science/texts.html⟩; [Ref. 12] ⟨www.sonnetusa.com/bio/maxbio.pdf⟩; [Ref. 64] ⟨www.hti.umich.edu/cgi/t/text/text-idx?c=moa;idno=ACS4850.0001.001⟩; [Ref. 88] ⟨www.ccel.org/ccel/orr/view.html⟩.
31.
Oxford Dictionary of National Biography
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford, 2004
).32.
Dictionary of National Biography
(Macmillan
, London, various dates).33.
Campbell and Garnett, Ref. 12, p.
191
.34.
Anon. [
R.
Chambers
], Vestiges of the Natural History of Creation
(Leicester University Press
, 1969
), reprint of the 1844 edition.35.
36.
Reference 6, p.
225
.37.
Reference 6, p.
226
.W.
Thomson
, “Note on some points in the theory of heat
,” Cambridge Math. J.
4
, 67
–72
(1845
), reprinted in W. Thomson, Mathematical and Physical Papers (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1882), Vol. 1, pp. 10–15.39.
R.
Clausius
, “On the second fundamental theorem of the mechanical theory of heat
,” Philos. Mag.
35
, 405
–419
(1868
).Maxwell may have only been referring to the publication by Clausius where the term “entropy” was introduced:
R.
Clausius
, Ann. Phys. Chem.
125
, 353
–400
(1865
).On Maxwell’s misinterpretation of entropy in BA1870 and in the early editions of Theory of Heat, see
E.
Garber
, “James Clerk Maxwell and thermodynamics
,” Am. J. Phys.
37
, 146
–154
(1969
).40.
P. G.
Tait
, “Section A…Opening Address
,” Nature (London)
4
, 270
–273
(1871
).41.
B. F.
Westcott
, The Epistle to the Hebrews: The Greek Text with Notes and Essays
(Macmillan
, London, 1906
), 3rd ed., pp. 7
–9
andB. F.
Westcott
, The Epistle to the Hebrews: The Greek Text with Notes and Essays
, (Macmillan
, London, 1906
), 3rd ed.,353
–356
.42.
Reference 6, p.
376
.43.
J. F. D.
Herschel
, A Preliminary Discourse on the Study of Natural Philosophy
(Longmans
, London, 1851
) Art. 28, p. 38
. The phrase “manufactured article
” is also used in Art. 28 of the first edition (1830).45.
46.
W. K.
Clifford
, Lectures and Essays
, edited by L.
Stephen
and F.
Pollock
(Macmillan
, London, 1879
), Vol. 1
, pp. 191
–227
.47.
J.
Tyndall
, “Inaugural Address (British Association)
,” Nature (London)
10
, 309
–319
(1874
).48.
C.
Pritchard
, Modern science and natural religion: an essay read before the Church Congress at Brighton, and now submitted to the members of the British Association who listened to the presidential address at Belfast
(Parker
, Oxford, 1874
).50.
G. G.
Stokes
, “On the bearings of the study of natural science, and of the contemplation of the discoveries to which that study leads, on our religious ideas
,” J. Transaction Victoria Institute
14
, 227
–247
(1880
); see the discussion on p. 247 following his address.51.
G. G.
Stokes
, Natural Theology, Gifford Lectures
(Macmillan
, London, 1894
), Vol. 2
, pp. 130
–134
.52.
54.
Reference 6, p.
482
.56.
Reference 52, p.
245
.57.
A.
Westcott
, Life and Letters of Brooke Foss Westcott
(Macmillan
, London, 1903
), Vol. 1
, p. 385
.58.
A. F.
Hort
, Life and Letters of Fenton John Anthony Hort
(Macmillan
, London, 1896
), Vol. 2
, p. 185
.59.
Anon, “
Bishop Lightfoot
,” Quarterly Review (London)
176
, 73
–105
(1893
).60.
J. B.
Lightfoot
, St. Paul’s Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon
(Macmillan
, London, 1875
).61.
Reference 12, p.
366
and62.
B. F.
Westcott
, The Gospel of Life: Thoughts Introductory to the Study of Christian Doctrine
(Macmillan
, London, 1892
), p. xvii
.63.
64.
B.
Stewart
, The Conservation of Energy: An Elementary Treatise on Energy and Its Laws
(King
, London, 1873
).66.
Maxwell had previously noted the historian Buckle in correspondence: Ref. 12, p.
295
.67.
B.
Stewart
, “The recent developments of cosmical physics
,” Nature (London)
2
, 499
–501
(1870
).68.
F.
Everitt
, “James Clerk Maxwell: A force for physics
,” Phys. World
19
(12
), 32
–37
(2006
).69.
Reference 57,
371
.70.
Reference 12, p.
358
, footnote.71.
72.
J. H.
Stirling
, Philosophy and theology, Gifford lectures
(Clark
, Edinburgh, 1890
), p. 220
.73.
Reference 29, p.
114
.74.
E.
Romanes
, The Life and Letters of George John Romanes
(Longmans
, London, 1896
), p. 161
.75.
J. E.
Lesch
, “Romanes, George John
,” in Dictionary of Scientific Biography
, edited by C. C.
Gillispie
(Scribner
, New York, 1974
), Vol. 11
, pp. 516
–520
.76.
77.
J.
Schwartz
, “George John Romanes’s defense of Darwinism: The correspondence of Charles Darwin and his chief disciple
,” J. Hist. Biology
28
, 281
–316
(1995
).78.
Reference 74, pp.
289
,79.
J. R.
Moore
, The Post-Darwinian Controversies: A Study of the Protestant Struggle to Come to Terms with Darwin in Great Britain and America, 1870–1900
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, 1979
), pp. 108
–109
,J. R.
Moore
, The Post-Darwinian Controversies: A Study of the Protestant Struggle to Come to Terms with Darwin in Great Britain and America, 1870–1900
(Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge, ),366
–367
.80.
F. M.
Turner
, Between Science and Religion: The Reaction to Scientific Naturalism in Late Victorian England
(Yale University Press
, New Haven, 1974
), pp. 160
–162
.81.
82.
83.
G. J.
Romanes
, Thoughts on Religion
(Longmans
, London, 1902
), pp. 137
–138
.84.
85.
C. J.
Ellicott
, Modern Unbelief: Its Principles and Characteristics
(Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge
, London 1877
). This book is noted in Ref. 11.86.
C. J.
Ellicott
, Six Addresses on the Being of God
(S.P.C.K.
, London, 1880
), pp. 55
–111
, 140–168.87.
Reference 86, p.
168
.88.
J.
Orr
, Christian View of God and the World
(Regent College Publishing
, Vancouver, 2002
), p. 150
andJ.
Orr
, Christian View of God and the World
(Regent College Publishing
, Vancouver, 2002
),p. 477
. First published in 1893.89.
S. N.
Williams
in the foreward (written in 2002) to Ref. 88.90.
J.
Orr
, “Science and Christian faith
,” in The Fundamentals: A Testimony to the Truth
, edited by R. A.
Torrey
and A. C.
Dixon
(Baker
, Grand Rapids, 1972
), Vol. 1
, pp. 334
–347
.91.
C. T.
McIntire
, “The fundamentals
,” in Evangelical Dictionary of Theology
, edited by W. A.
Elwell
(Baker
, Grand Rapids, 1984
), p. 436
.92.
C. B.
Tayler
, Montague; or, Is This Religion?
(Smith & Elder
, London, 1833
), pp. 52
–143
.93.
C. B.
Tayler
, Facts in a Clergyman’s Life
(Stanford & Swords
, New York, 1849
), pp. 24
–28
, 52–58, 106–114, 183–193, 241–269.94.
95.
Reference 12, footnote, p.
345
.96.
D.
Bebbington
, “The life of Baptist Noel: Its setting and significance
,” Baptist Quarterly
24
, 389
–418
(1972
).97.
C. H.
Spurgeon
, Autobiography: Vol. 2: The Full Harvest 1860–1892
, edited by S.
Spurgeon
and J.
Harrald
(Banner of Truth
, Edinburgh, 1976
), p. 437
.98.
C. H.
Spurgeon
, The Sword and the Trowel
, 1
(2
), 67
–72
(1865
). Reprinted in C. H. Spurgeon’s Works (Pilgrim Publications, Pasadena, TX, 1975).99.
100.
101.
J.
Offord
, Notes of Sermons
(Partridge
, London, 1870
). The British Library record indicates the notes were taken by a member of the congregation (C. Soares).102.
Anon, “Obituary: John Offord,” in
The Baptist Handbook
(1870
), pp. 198
–199
.103.
H. C.
Bolton
and W. C.
Price
, “The date of birth of James Clerk Maxwell
,” Notes and Records, Roy. Soc. London
32
, 213
–214
(1978
).104.
106.
W. E.
Gladstone
, British Library MS 44767, f. 8. Gladstone read Ref. 12 from 21 Jan.–10 Feb. 1883. See The Gladstone Diaries
, edited by H. C. G.
Matthew
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford, 1990
), Vol. 10
, pp. 398
–404
.107.
108.
109.
G. G.
Stokes
, On Light, Burnett Lectures
(Macmillan
, London, 1892
), Lecture 4 of Course 3, pp. 325
–343
.110.
D. B.
Wilson
, “A physicist’s alternative to materialism: The religious thought of George Gabriel Stokes
,” Victorian Studies
28
, 69
–96
(1984
).111.
P. G.
Tait
, “Does humanity require a new revelation?
” International Review
5
, 721
–733
(1878
).112.
113.
Anon, “
The late Professor Clifford’s Essays
,” Edinburgh Review
151
, 474
–511
(1880
). Because of its length, this review was probably not written by Maxwell.114.
J.
Ward
, Naturalism and Agnosticism: The Gifford Lectures Delivered before the University of Aberdeen in the Years 1896-1898
(Black
, London, 1915
), pp. 88
–116
.115.
116.
E.
Rutherford
and F.
Soddy
, “Radioactive change
,” Philos. Mag.
5
, 576
–591
(1903
).117.
118.
J. D.
Barrow
and F. J.
Tipler
, The Anthropic Cosmological Principle
(Oxford University Press
, Oxford, 1986
).119.
F. C.
Adams
and G.
Laughlin
, “A dying universe: The long-term fate and evolution of astrophysical objects
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
69
, 337
–372
(1997
).120.
E. E.
Salpeter
, “Stellar nucleosynthesis
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
71
, S220
–S222
(1999
).121.
W.
Thomson
, “On the universal tendency in nature to the dissipation of mechanical energy
,” Philos. Mag.
4
, 304
–306
(1852
);“
The kinetic theory of the dissipation of energy
,” Proc. R. Soc. Edinburgh
8
, 325
–334
(1874
).122.
H.
Helmholtz
, “On the interaction of natural forces
,” Philos. Mag.
11
, 489
–518
(1856
), translated from an 1854 publication.123.
L.
Boltzmann
, “Weitere Studien über das Wärmegleichgewicht unter Gasmolekülen
,” Wien. Ber.
66
, 275
–370
(1972
).Boltzmann gave here what became known as the H-theorem. For Boltzmann’s other work see
J. L.
Lebowitz
, “A selective review of two central issues
,” Rev. Mod. Phys.
71
, S346
–S357
(1999
);S. G.
Brush
, “Gadflies and geniuses in the history of gas theory
,” Synthese
119
, 11
–43
(1999
).124.
Reference 11, p.
418
.125.
Reference 58, p.
276
.126.
J.
Macaulay
, James Clerk Maxwell, F. R. S.
(Religious Tract Society
, London, n.d.);reprinted in:
Short Biographies for the People
(Religious Tract Society
, London, 1885
), biography No. 14.127.
Lord
Rayleigh
(J. W. Strutt), “Presidential address
,” British Association Report, 1
–23
(1884
).128.
R. J.
Strutt
, Life of John William Strutt, Third Baron Rayleigh
(University of Wisconsin
, Madison, 1968
), p. 360
.130.
F.
Bowers
, A Bold Experiment: The Story of Bloomsbury Chapel and Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church 1848–1999
(Bloomsbury Central Baptist Church
, London, 1999
), p. 115
.131.
W. B.
Neatby
, A History of the Plymouth Brethren
(Tentmaker Publications
, Stoke-on-Trent, 2001
), retypeset from 1901 edition, pp. 101
–182
.132.
J. D.
Burnham
, A Story of Conflict: The Controversial Relationship Between Benjamin Wills Newton and John Nelson Darby
(Paternoster
, Carlisle, 2004
), pp. 149
–231
.133.
A short letter from Offord is briefly quoted and criticized in one pamphlet by a follower of Darby:
W.
Trotter
, What are Mr. Newton’s Present Doctrines
(Rowe
, Plymouth, 1850
).134.
© 2007 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2007
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.
