The interpretation of the expanding universe as an expansion of space has recently been challenged. From the geodesic equation in Friedmann universe models and the empty Milne model, we argue that a Newtonian or special relativistic analysis is not applicable on large scales, and the general relativistic interpretation in terms of expanding space has the advantage of being globally consistent. We also show that the cosmic redshift, interpreted as an expansion effect, contains both the Doppler effect and the gravitational frequency shift.
REFERENCES
1.
J. A.
Peacock
, “An introduction to the physics of cosmology
,” in Modern Cosmology, Proceedings of the Como School 2000
, edited by S.
Bonometto
, V.
Gorini
, and U.
Moschella
(IOP
, Bristol, 2002
), p. 9
.2.
3.
A. B.
Whiting
, “The expansion of space: Free particle motion and the cosmological redshift
,” Observatory
124
, 174
–189
(2004
).4.
T. M.
Davis
, C. H.
Lineweaver
, and J. K.
Webb
, “Solutions to the tethered galaxy problem in an expanding universe and the observation of receding blueshifted objects
,” Am. J. Phys.
71
, 358
–364
(2003
).5.
T. M.
Davis
and C. H.
Lineweaver
, “Expanding confusion: Common misconceptions of cosmological horizons and the superluminal expansion of the universe
,” Publ. - Astron. Soc. Aust.
21
, 97
–109
(2004
).6.
C. H.
Lineweaver
and T. M.
Davis
, “Misconceptions about the big bang
,” Sci. Am.
292
(3
), 24
–33
(2005
).7.
F. J.
Tipler
, “Newtonian cosmology revisited
,” Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.
282
, 206
–210
(1996
).8.
F. J.
Tipler
, “Rigorous Newtonian cosmology
,” Am. J. Phys.
64
, 1311
–1315
(1996
).9.
J. A.
Morgan
, “Are galaxies receding or is space expanding
,” Am. J. Phys.
56
, 777
(1988
).10.
C. W.
Misner
, K. S.
Thorne
, and J. A.
Wheeler
, Gravitation
(Freeman
, San Francisco, 1973
), p. 284
.11.
S.
Carroll
, Spacetime and Geometry: An Introduction to General Relativity
(Addison-Wesley
, Reading, MA, 2004
), p. 93
.12.
R.
Gautreau
, “Imbedding a Schwarzschild mass into cosmology
,” Phys. Rev. D
29
, 198
–206
(1984
).13.
Ø.
Grøn
and P. D.
Rippis
, “Singular shell embedded into a cosmological model
,” Gen. Relativ. Gravit.
35
, 2189
–2215
(2003
).14.
15.
H. P.
Robertson
and T. W.
Noonan
, Relativity and Cosmology
(Saunders
, Philadelphia, 1968
), Sec. 16.1.16.
H.
Bondi
, “Spherically symmetrical models in general relativity
,” Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc.
107
, 410
–425
(1947
).17.
J. A.
Peacock
, Cosmological Physics
(Cambridge U. P.
, Cambridge, 1998
), Exer. 3.4.18.
Y. B.
Zeldovich
and I. D.
Novikov
, Relativistic Astrophysics
(Univ. of Chicago
, Chicago, 1983
).19.
20.
© 2007 American Association of Physics Teachers.
2007
American Association of Physics Teachers
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.