The one-dimensional fall of a folded chain with one end suspended from a rigid support and a chain falling from a resting heap on a table is studied. Because their Lagrangians contain no explicit time dependence, the falling chains are conservative systems. Their equations of motion are shown to contain a term that enforces energy conservation when masses are transferred between subchains. We show that Cayley’s 1857 energy nonconserving solution for a chain falling from a resting heap is incorrect because it neglects the energy gained when a link leaves a subchain. The maximum chain tension measured by Calkin and March for the falling folded chain is given a simple if rough interpretation. Other aspects of the falling folded chain are briefly discussed.

1.
M. G.
Calkin
and
R. H.
March
, “
The dynamics of a falling chain. I
,”
Am. J. Phys.
57
,
154
157
(
1989
).
2.
W.
Bragg
,
The World of Sound
(
Dover
,
New York
,
1968
), p.
184
.
3.
A.
Goriely
and
T.
McMillen
, “
Shape of a cracking whip
,”
Phys. Rev. Lett.
88
,
244301
1
244301
4
(
2002
).
4.
W.
Kurcharsky
, “
Zur Kinetik dehungsloser Seile mit Knickstellen
,”
Ing.-Arch.
12
,
109
123
(
1941
).
5.
R. M.
Rosenberg
,
Analytic Mechanics of Discrete Systems
(
Plenum
,
New York
,
1977
), pp.
332
334
.
6.
A. E. H.
Love
,
Theoretical Mechanics
, 3rd ed. (
Cambridge U.P.
,
Cambridge
,
1921
), p.
261
.
7.
H.
Lamb
,
Dynamics
, 2nd ed., (
Cambridge U.P.
,
Cambridge
,
1923
), Chap. VII, Example XII.5, p.
149
.
8.
W.
Chester
,
Mechanics
(
Allen & Unwin
,
London
,
1979
), Exercise 8.30, p.
241
.
9.
A.
Sommerfeld
,
Lectures on Theoretical Physics
(
Academic
,
New York
,
1952
), Vol.
I
, Mechanics, pp.
28
,
29
, and Problem I.7 on p.
241
, and solution on p.
257
.
10.
W. W.
Rouse Ball
,
A Short Account of the History of Mathematics
(
Dover
,
New York
,
1960
), p.
428
.
11.
C. C.
Gillispie
,
Lazare Carnot Savant
(
Princeton University Press
,
Princeton
,
1971
), p.
57
, where an English translation is given of the relevant sentences from Carnot’s book, Essai sur les Machines (
Dijon
,
Burgundy
,
1783
), Article LIX, pp.
91
92
.
12.
J. L.
Lagrange
,
Mécanique Analytique
, English translation of the second edition of 1811∕1815 by
A.
Boissonnade
and
V. N.
Vagliente
(
Kluwer
,
Dordrecht
,
1997
), Part II, Sec. III, Art. 5–6, pp.
192
193
.
13.
E. T.
Whittaker
,
A Treatise on the Analytic Dynamics of Particles and Rigid Bodies
(
Dover
,
New York
,
1944
), pp.
48
51
.
14.
G.
Hamel
,
Theoretische Mechanik
, Grundlehren der Mathematischen Wissenschaften, Bd LVII (
Springer
,
Berlin
,
1949
), Aufgabe 100, pp.
643
645
.
15.
M.
Schagerl
,
A.
Steindl
,
W.
Steiner
, and
H.
Troger
, “
On the paradox of the free falling folded chain
,”
Acta Mech.
125
,
155
168
(
1997
).
17.
J. B.
Marion
and
S. T.
Thornton
,
Classical Dynamics
, 4th ed. (
Saunders
,
Fort Worth, TX
,
1995
), pp.
338
340
.
18.
J. L.
Meriam
and
L. G.
Kraige
,
Engineering Mechanics
, 5th ed. (
Wiley
,
New York
,
2002
), Vol.
II
, Problems 4∕88 and 4∕90, p.
311
.
19.
S. T.
Thornton
and
J. B.
Marion
,
Classical Dynamics
, 5th ed. (
Brooks∕Cole
,
Belmont, CA
,
2004
), pp.
333
335
.
20.
W.
Steiner
and
H.
Troger
, “
On the equations of motion of the folded inextensible string
,”
Z. Angew. Math. Phys.
46
,
960
970
(
1995
).
21.
E. B.
Crellin
,
F.
Janssens
,
D.
Poelaert
,
W.
Steiner
, and
H.
Troger
, “
On balance and variational formulations of the equation of motion of a body deploying along a cable
,”
J. Appl. Mech.
64
,
369
374
(
1997
).
22.
H.
Irschik
and
H. J.
Holl
, “
Mechanics of variable-mass systems. I. Balance of mass and linear momentum
,”
Appl. Mech. Rev.
57
,
145
160
(
2004
).
23.
H.
Irschik
and
H. J.
Holl
, “
The equations of Lagrange written for a non-material volume
,”
Acta Mech.
153
,
231
248
(
2002
).
24.
A.
Cayley
, “
On a class of dynamical problems
,”
Proc. R. Soc. London
8
,
506
511
(
1857
).
25.
Reference 6, p.
260
.
26.
Reference 7, pp.
143
144
.
27.
E. J.
Saletan
and
A. H.
Cromer
,
Theoretical Mechanics
(
Wiley
,
New York
,
1971
), p.
25
and Problem 13, p.
28
.
28.
R.
Chicon
, “
Comment on ‘The falling chain and energy loss’ by David Keiffer
,”
Am. J. Phys.
71
,
951
952
(
2003
).
29.
Reference 17, Problem 9–15, p.
376
.
30.
Reference 19, Problem 9–15, p.
380
.
31.
J. B.
Marion
and
S. T.
Thornton
, Instructor’s Manual for Ref. 17, Problem 9–15, pp.
228
229
.
32.
S. T.
Thornton
and
J. B.
Marion
, Instructor’s Manual for Ref. 19 (available to instructors from the Thomson:Brooks∕Cole web site as a downloadable electronic file), Chap. 6, Problem 9–15, pp.
11
12
.
33.
C. A.
de Sousa
and
V. H.
Rodrigues
, “
Mass redistribution in variable mass systems
,”
Eur. J. Phys.
25
,
41
49
(
2004
).
34.
J. P.
Thorpe
, “
On the momentum theorem for a continuous system of variable masses
,”
Am. J. Phys.
30
,
637
640
(
1962
).
35.
M. S.
Tiersten
, “
Force, momentum change and motion
,”
Am. J. Phys.
37
,
82
87
(
1969
).
36.
J.
Matolyak
and
G.
Matous
, “
Simple variable mass systems: Newton’s second law
,”
Phys. Teach.
28
,
328
329
(
1990
).
37.
W. R.
Hamilton
, “
Second essay on a general method in dynamics
,”
Philos. Trans. R. Soc. London
125
,
95
144
(
1835
); see especially p. 98.
38.
R.
Dugas
,
A History of Mechanics
(
Griffon
,
Neuchatel, Switzerland
,
1955
), pp.
398
399
.
39.
Reference 12, Part II, Sec. IV, Art. 10, pp.
230
231
.
40.
Refernce 12, Part II, Sec. IV, Art. 14, pp.
233
234
.
41.
Reference 12, Part II, Sec. III, Art. 2–3, pp.
190
192
.
42.
J. G.
Papastavridis
,
Analytic Mechanics
(
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford
,
2002
), p.
787
.
44.
W.
Tomaszewski
and
P.
Pieranski
, “
Dynamics of ropes and chains. I. The fall of the folded chain
,”
New J. Phys.
7
,
45
61
(
2005
).
46.
M.
Kline
,
Mathematical Thought from Ancient to Modern Times
(
Oxford University Press
,
Oxford
,
1972
), Vol.
II
, Chap. 24, pp.
573
591
.
47.
D. J.
Struik
,
A Concise History of Mathematics
, 3th revised ed. (
Dover
,
New York
,
1967
), p.
134
.
48.
Reference 12, p.
7
.
49.
Reference 10, pp.
401
412
.
50.
C.
Truesdell
,
Essays in the History of Mechanics
(
Springer
,
Berlin
,
1968
), p.
133
.
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.