We investigate the difficulties that students in calculus-based introductory physics courses have with the concepts of symmetry, electric field, and electric flux which are important for applying Gauss’s law. The determination of the electric field using Gauss’s law requires determining the symmetry of a particular charge distribution and predicting the direction of the electric field everywhere if a high symmetry exists. Effective application of Gauss’s law implicitly requires understanding the principle of superposition for electric fields. Helping students learn when Gauss’s law can be readily applied to determine the strength of the electric field, and then helping them learn to determine the appropriate shape of Gaussian surfaces if sufficient symmetry exists, can help develop their reasoning and problem-solving skills. We administered free-response and multiple-choice questions and conducted interviews with individual students using a think-aloud protocol to elucidate the difficulties that students have with the concepts of symmetry, electric field, and electric flux. We also developed a multiple-choice test that targets these conceptual issues to obtain quantitative information about their difficulties and administered it to 541 students in the introductory calculus-based physics courses and to upper-level undergraduates in an electricity and magnetism course and to graduate students enrolled in a teaching assistant seminar course. We find that undergraduate students have many common difficulties with these concepts.

1.
A.
Van Heuvelen
, “
Learning to think like a physicist: A review of research-based instructional strategies
,”
Am. J. Phys.
59
,
891
(
1991
);
A.
Van Heuvelen
, “
Overview, case study physics
,”
Am. J. Phys.
59
,
898
907
(
1991
).
2.
D. E.
Meltzer
and
K.
Manivannan
, “
Transforming the lecture hall environment: The fully interactive physics lecture
,”
Am. J. Phys.
70
(
6
),
639
654
(
2002
).
3.
E. F.
Redish
,
J. M.
Saul
, and
R. N.
Steinberg
, “
On the effectiveness of active-engagement microcomputer-based laboratories
,”
Am. J. Phys.
65
,
45
54
(
1997
).
4.
D.
Zollman
, “
Millikan lecture 1995: Do they just sit there? Reflections on helping students learn physics
,”
Am. J. Phys.
64
(
2
),
113
119
(
1996
).
5.
M. T. H.
Chi
, “
Thinking aloud
,” in
The Think Aloud Method
, edited by
M. W.
van Someren
,
Y. F.
Barnard
, and
J. A. C.
Sandberg
(
Academic Press
, London,
1994
), Chap. 1.
6.
D.
Maloney
,
T.
O’Kuma
,
C.
Hieggelke
, and
A. V.
Heuvelen
, “
Surveying students’ conceptual knowledge of electricity and magnetism
,”
Am. J. Phys.
69
,
S12
S23
(
2001
).
7.
L. C.
McDermott
and
P. S.
Shaffer
, “
Research as a guide for curriculum development: An example from introductory electricity. Part I: Investigation of student understanding
,”
Am. J. Phys.
60
,
994
1003
(
1992
);
Erratum,
L. C.
McDermott
, and
P. S.
Shaffer
,
Am. J. Phys.
61
,
81
(
1993
);
P. S.
Shaffer
and
L. C.
McDermott
, “
Research as a guide for curriculum development: An example from introductory electricity. Part II: Design of an instructional strategy
,”
Am. J. Phys.
60
,
1003
1013
(
1992
).
8.
P.
Engelhard
and
R.
Beichner
, “
Students’ understanding of direct current electrical circuits
,”
Am. J. Phys.
72
,
98
113
(
2004
).
9.
S.
Rainson
,
G.
Transtromer
, and
L.
Viennot
, “
Students’ understanding of superposition of electric fields
,”
Am. J. Phys.
62
(
11
),
1026
1032
(
1994
).
11.
For example, see ⟨http://www.opensourcephsyics.org ⟩, and
W.
Christian
and
M.
Belloni
,
Physlet Physics
(
Prentice-Hall
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ,
2004
).
12.
L. C.
McDermott
,
P. S.
Shaffer
, and the Physics Education Group, University of Washington
Tutorials in Introductory Physics
(
Prentice Hall
, NJ,
2002
).
13.
D.
Hestenes
,
M.
Wells
, and
G.
Swackhamer
, “
Force Concept Inventory
,”
Phys. Teach.
30
,
141
158
(
1992
).
14.
R.
Thornton
and
D.
Sokoloff
, “
Assessing student learning of Newton’s laws: The force and motion conceptual evaluation and the evaluation of active learning laboratory and lecture curricula
,”
Am. J. Phys.
66
,
338
352
(
1998
).
15.
C.
Singh
and
D.
Rosengrant
, “
Multiple-choice test of energy and momentum concepts
,”
Am. J. Phys.
71
(
6
),
607
617
(
2003
).
16.
G.
Aubrecht
and
J.
Aubrecht
, “
Constructing objective tests
,”
Am. J. Phys.
51
,
613
620
(
1983
);
A. J.
Nitko
,
Educational Assessments of Students
, 2nd ed. (
Prentice-Hall/Merrill
, Englewood Cliffs, NJ,
1996
).
17.
B.
Bloom
,
G.
Madaus
, and
J.
Hastings
,
Evaluation to Improve Learning
(
McGraw-Hill
, New York,
1981
).
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.