Recently a suggestion was made that standard textbook representations of hypersurfaces of simultaneity for the traveling twin in the twin “paradox” are incorrect. This suggestion is false: The textbooks are in agreement with a correct understanding of the relativity of simultaneity.

1.
C. E.
Dolby
and
S. F.
Gull
, “
On radar time and the twin ‘paradox
’,”
Am. J. Phys.
69
(
12
),
1257
1261
(
2001
).
2.
R.
D’Inverno
,
Introducing Einstein's Relativity
(
Oxford University Press
, Oxford,
1992
).
3.
L.
Sartori
,
Understanding Relativity: a simplified approach to Einstein's theories
(
University of California Press
, Berkeley,
1996
).
4.
A.
Einstein
, “
On the electrodynamics of moving bodies
,”
Ann. Phys.
17
,
891
921
(
1905
).
5.
D.
Malament
, “
Causal theories of time and the conventionality of simultaneity
,”
Noûs
11
(
3
),
293
300
(
1977
).
6.
T. A.
Debs
and
M. L.G.
Redhead
, “
The twin ‘paradox’ and the conventionality of simultaneity
,”
Am. J. Phys.
64
(
4
),
384
392
(
1996
).
7.
S.
Sarkar
and
J.
Stachel
, “
Did Malament prove the non-conventionality of simultaneity in the special theory of relativity
?,”
Philos. Sci.
66
(
2
),
208
220
(
1999
).
8.
M.
Friedman
,
Foundations of Space-Time Theories
(
Princeton University Press
, Princeton,
1983
), p.
166
.
9.
D.
Giulini
, “
Uniqueness of simultaneity
,”
Br. J. Philos. Sci.
52
,
651
670
(
2001
).
10.
A. A.
Robb
,
A Theory of Time and Space
(
Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge,
1914
).
11.
H.
Bondi
,
Assumption and Myth in Physical Theory
(
Cambridge University Press
, Cambridge,
1967
).
12.
S. F.
Gull
, personal communication, 10 January
2005
.
13.
C. E.
Dolby
and
S. F.
Gull
, “
State-space-based approach to quantum field theory for arbitrary observers in electromagnetic backgrounds
,”
Ann. Phys. (N.Y.)
293
(
2
),
189
214
(
2001
), especially Sec. 4.
14.
H.
Halvorson
and
R.
Clifton
, “
No place for particles in relativistic quantum theories?
,”
Philos. Sci.
69
(
1
),
1
28
(
2002
).
15.
D.
Malament
, “
In defense of dogma: Why there cannot be a relativistic quantum mechanics of (localizable) particles
,” in
Perspectives on Quantum Reality
, edited by
R.
Clifton
(
Kluwer
, Dordrecht,
1996
), pp.
1
10
.
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.