Physicists often claim that there is an effective repulsion between fermions, implied by the Pauli principle, and a corresponding effective attraction between bosons. We examine the origins and validity of such exchange force ideas and the areas where they are highly misleading. We propose that explanations of quantum statistics should avoid the idea of an effective force completely, and replace it with more appropriate physical insights, some of which are suggested here.

1.
D. Layzer, “The synergy between writing and mathematics,” in Writing to Learn Mathematics and Science, edited by Paul Connolly and Teresa Vilardi (Teacher College Press, New York, 1989).
2.
C. V. Heer, Statistical Mechanics, Kinetic Theory, and Stochastic Processes (Academic, New York, 1972), p. 209.
3.
J. J. Brehm and W. J. Mullin, Introduction to the Structure of Matter (Wiley, New York, 1989).
4.
R. K. Pathria, Statistical Mechanics, 2nd ed. (Butterworth-Heinemann, Oxford, 1996), p. 124.
5.
K. Huang, Statistical Mechanics, 2nd ed. (Wiley, New York, 1987), p. 203.
6.
G. E.
Uhlenbeck
and
L.
Gropper
, “
The equation of state of a non-ideal Einstein–Bose or Fermi–Dirac gas
,”
Phys. Rev.
41
,
79
90
(
1932
).
7.
G. H. Wannier, Statistical Physics (Wiley, New York, 1966), p. 179.
8.
R. B. Leighton, Principles of Modern Physics (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1959), p. 239.
9.
D. J. Griffiths, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics (Prentice-Hall, Englewood Cliffs, NJ, 1995), p. 184.
10.
Huang, Ref. 5, Chap. 10.
11.
K. Krane, Modern Physics (Wiley, New York, 1996), p. 508.
12.
Huang, Ref. 5, Chap. 11.
13.
S. Chandrasekhar, An Introduction to the Study of Stellar Structure (Dover, New York, 1957).
14.
S. D. Kawaler, I. Novikov, and G. Srinivasan, Stellar Remnants (Springer, Berlin, 1997).
15.
E.
Witten
, “
Cosmic separation of phases
,”
Phys. Rev. D
30
,
272
285
(
1984
).
16.
E. G. Harris, Introduction to Modern Theoretical Physics (Wiley, New York, 1975), Vol. 2, p. 532.
17.
C.
Herring
, “
Critique of the Heitler–London method of calculating spin couplings at large distances
,”
Rev. Mod. Phys.
34
,
631
645
(
1962
);
Magnetism, edited by G. T. Rado and H. Suhl (Academic, New York, 1966), Vol. IIB, Chap. 1.
18.
E.
Lieb
and
D.
Mattis
, “
Theory of ferromagnetism and the ordering of electronic energy levels
,”
Phys. Rev.
125
,
164
172
(
1962
).
19.
Equation (23) can be given a rigorous derivation (Refs. 17 and 20) in which the factor σ1⋅σ2 arises from the spin pair-permutation operator P12(S)=1/2(1+σ1⋅σ2) acting on spin-space functions to ensure correct overall wave function antisymmetry. The H2 problem has analogs in many body physics in the Heisenberg Hamiltonians of electron magnetism (Refs. 17 and 18) and of nuclear magnetism of solid He3 (Refs. 21 and 22).
20.
P. A. M. Dirac, The Principles of Quantum Mechanics, 4th ed. (Oxford Press, London, 1958), p. 224.
21.
D. J.
Thouless
, “
Exchange in solid He3 and the Heisenberg Hamiltonian
,”
Proc. Phys. Soc. London
86
,
893
904
(
1965
).
22.
A. K.
McMahan
, “
Critique of recent theories of exchange in solid He3
,”
J. Low Temp. Phys.
8
,
115
158
(
1972
).
23.
The idea that the energy lowering in the H2 molecule comes from electrons tunneling in a six-dimensional hyperspace from one site pair to the opposite can be strengthened by expressing J in terms of a surface integral (Ref. 17). This surface integral represents a particle current crossing a hypersurface separating the two localized site arrangements (a,b) and (b,a).
24.
That the energy splitting between symmetric and antisymmetric states of fermions does not arise from antisymmetrization, but would occur as well for distinguishable particles, has been pointed out in reference to the helium atom in C. Cohen-Tannoudji, B. Diu, and F. Laloë, Quantum Mechanics (Wiley, New York, 1977), p. 1427.
25.
J. M. Ziman, Principles of the Theory of Solids (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1965).
26.
Reference 4, p. 241.
27.
At large separation r between the nuclei of the atoms, the potential is usually well described as a dispersion or van der Waal’s interaction (due to virtual induced electric dipoles not included in the H2 discussion), which varies as −1/r6. The parameters for phenomenological interatomic potentials are determined from scattering data or thermal data.
28.
For a review, see C. J. Pethick and H. Smith, Bose–Einstein Condensation in Dilute Gases (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2002).
29.
R. P. Feynman, Statistical Mechanics (Benjamin, Reading, MA, 1972), p. 328.
30.
For simplicity, we have assumed that the scattering potential is azimuthally symmetric, as it is in so many applications, so that there is no dependence on the angle φ.
31.
Francis Halzen and Alan D. Martin, Quarks and Leptons: An Introductory Course in Modern Particle Physics (Wiley, New York, 1984), p. 119.
32.
F. Reif, Fundamentals of Statistical and Thermal Physics (McGraw-Hill, New York, 1965), p. 480.
33.
C.
Lhuillier
and
F.
Laloë
, “
Transport properties in a spin polarized gas. I
,”
J. Phys. (France)
43
,
197
224
(
1982
).
34.
W. J.
Mullin
and
K.
Miyake
, “
Exact transport properties of degenerate, weakly interacting, and spin-polarized Fermions
,”
J. Low Temp. Phys.
53
,
313
338
(
1983
).
35.
A. E. Meyerovich, “Spin-polarized phases of He3,” in Helium Three, edited by W. P. Halperin and L. P. Pitaevskii (Elsevier Science, B. V., Amsterdam, 1990), Chap. 13.
36.
M.
Leduc
,
P. J.
Nacher
,
D. S.
Betts
,
J. M.
Daniels
,
G.
Tastevin
, and
F.
Laloë
, “
Nuclear polarization and heat conduction changes in gaseous He3
,”
Europhys. Lett.
4
,
59
63
(
1987
).
37.
Paul G. Hewitt, Conceptual Physics (Prentice-Hall, New York, 2001).
This content is only available via PDF.
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.