The average distance between a star and a planet in the classic two-body problem of celestial mechanics is different from the orbital semi-major axis of the planet if the average is performed over time or angle. The time- and angle-averaged distances are functions of both the semi-major axis and the orbital eccentricity and can differ from the orbital semi-major axis by as much as 50%–100%. This difference contradicts the usual statement found in most introductory and advanced textbooks that the average distance and the orbital semi-major axis are equal.

1.
See for example W. K. Hartmann and C. Impey, Astronomy: The Cosmic Journey (Brooks/Cole, 2002), 6th ed., p. 59;
J. Bennett, M. Donahue, N. Schneider, and M. Voit, The Cosmic Perspective (Addison–Wesley, Reading, MA, 2002), 2nd ed., p. 136;
M. A. Seeds, Horizons: Exploring the Universe (Brooks/Cole, 2002), 7th ed., p. 54. Perhaps the best example of the “average-distance” statement is that made by the late astronomer Carl Sagan in Episode 3 of his popular COSMOS television series which aired in the Fall of 1980 on PBS.
2.
M. Zeilik, S. A. Gregory, and E. v. P. Smith, Introductory Astronomy and Astrophysics (Saunders College Publishing, Philadelphia, 1992), 3rd ed., p. 8. Here, the authors state that “(t)he mean distance from the Sun to a planet in (an) elliptical orbit is just the semi-major axis a. We prove this fact by noting that for each point … on an ellipse there is a symmetrical point (about the minor axis) from the focus … (and) the average of these distances is a.” Unfortunately, the authors do not say that a circumferential averaging of the planet–sun separation is the only way to obtain this result analytically.
3.
For a review, see
D. M.
Williams
and
D.
Pollard
, “
Earth-like worlds on eccentric orbits: Excursions beyond the habitable zone
,”
Int. J. Astrobio.
1
(
4
),
61
69
(
2002
).
4.
Actually, the problem is more widespread. See for example the advanced texts by B. W. Carroll and D. A. Ostlie, An Introduction to Modern Astrophysics (Addison–Wesley, Readings, MA, 1996), p. 27, and J. M. A. Danby, Fundamentals of Celestial Mechanics (Willmann-Bell, 1988), 2nd ed., p. 5.
This content is only available via PDF.
AAPT members receive access to the American Journal of Physics and The Physics Teacher as a member benefit. To learn more about this member benefit and becoming an AAPT member, visit the Joining AAPT page.