We analyze the problem-solving strategies of physics professors in a case where their physical intuition fails. A nonintuitive introductory-level problem was identified and posed to twenty physics professors. The problem placed the professors in a situation often encountered by students, and their response highlights the importance of intuition and experience in problem solving. Although professors had difficulty in solving the problem under the time constraint, they initially employed a systematic approach, for example, visualizing the problem, considering various conservation laws, and examining limiting cases. After finding that familiar techniques were not fruitful, they made incorrect predictions based on one of two equally important factors. In contrast, other more familiar problems that require the consideration of two important principles (for example, conservation of both energy and momentum for a ballistic pendulum) were quickly solved by the same professors. The responses of students who were given the same problem reflected no overarching strategies or systematic approaches, and a much wider variety of incorrect responses were given. This investigation highlights the importance of teaching effective problem-solving heuristics, and suggests that instructors assess the difficulty of a problem from the perspective of beginning students.
Skip Nav Destination
Article navigation
November 2002
PAPERS|
November 01 2002
When physical intuition fails
Chandralekha Singh
Chandralekha Singh
Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of Pittsburgh, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania 15260
Search for other works by this author on:
Am. J. Phys. 70, 1103–1109 (2002)
Article history
Received:
March 14 2002
Accepted:
August 16 2002
Citation
Chandralekha Singh; When physical intuition fails. Am. J. Phys. 1 November 2002; 70 (11): 1103–1109. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.1512659
Download citation file:
Sign in
Don't already have an account? Register
Sign In
You could not be signed in. Please check your credentials and make sure you have an active account and try again.
Pay-Per-View Access
$40.00
Citing articles via
Playing with active matter
Angelo Barona Balda, Aykut Argun, et al.
A simple model of a gravitational lens from geometric optics
Bogdan Szafraniec, James F. Harford
All objects and some questions
Charles H. Lineweaver, Vihan M. Patel
A simplified relativity experiment
David P. Jackson, Fedya Grishanov, et al.
Related Content
Friction and the Intuition-Outcome Disparity
Phys. Teach. (March 2014)
Friction and the Intuition-Outcome Disparity
Phys. Teach. (February 2014)
One model for an integrated math/physics course focusing on electricity and magnetism and related calculus topics
American Journal of Physics (August 2000)
College Students’ Intuitive Understanding and Problem‐Solving of Energy and Momentum
AIP Conference Proceedings (July 2010)
A More Intuitive Version of the Lorentz Velocity Addition Formula
The Physics Teacher (October 2009)